Best Hallmark Halloween Movies Ranked by Audience Reviews

Hallmark knows how to fill December with romance, but its Halloween lineup is a much smaller treat bag. Dig past the network’s autumn romances and early Christmas premieres, though, and you’ll find costume balls, haunted houses, mischievous ghosts, and an impressive run of Good Witch specials. These are the 10 best Hallmark Halloween and Halloween-adjacent movies, ranked by audience reviews. The biggest surprise? Some of the most seasonal entries don’t make it anywhere near the top.

10–7: Halloween spirit, with a little room for debate

Not every movie here takes place on Halloween night. Some earn a spot through trick-or-treating, costumes, or a well-timed ghost, making them ideal if you want a hint of spooky season without an actual scare.

10. Oliver’s Ghost (2011)

One of Hallmark’s earlier Halloween-friendly releases starts with a boy moving into a house and befriending its resident ghost. Oliver’s Ghost is more family ghost story than full-on holiday movie, but jack-o’-lantern carving and trick-or-treating make it a fair pick for an October watchlist.

Its IMDb weighted audience average is 5.9 out of 10, though its unweighted average is a warmer 6.5. The most common individual score is a perfect 10, suggesting that this modest little movie really stuck the landing for some viewers.

9. Haul Out the Halloween (2025)

What happens when Halloween fans move into a neighborhood that seems to save all its enthusiasm for Christmas? They try to change the culture, of course. The premise gives Haul Out the Halloween an amusingly self-aware edge, especially for a Hallmark movie, given the network’s famously early holiday pivot.

Viewers have been moderately receptive. Its IMDb weighted average is 6.0 out of 10, its unweighted average is 6.3, and its most common individual rating is 6.

8. Midnight Masquerade (2014)

If your perfect Halloween movie involves a costume ball but absolutely must include corporate legal trouble, here’s your oddly specific match. Midnight Masquerade gives a gender-swapped Cinderella-style setup a Hallmark rom-com makeover, trading glass-slipper magic for a story about a major lawsuit.

The Halloween ball supplies the seasonal sparkle, while the romance does the rest. IMDb users give it a 6.3 weighted average, a 6.5 unweighted average, and a most common individual rating of 6.

7. Haunted Wedding (2024)

Ghost hunters Brian and Jana choose a haunted hotel for their wedding, which already sounds like tempting fate. Then a ghost decides Brian is actually her fiancé. It’s a supernatural complication that this couple, of all people, should have seen coming.

Haunted Wedding has a 6.3 weighted average on IMDb, matching its 6.3 unweighted average. Its most common individual score is 7.

6–4: Romance, real estate, and a rising dose of magic

The middle of the ranking shows just how broad Hallmark’s version of Halloween can be. One movie uses the holiday as a romantic backdrop, another gives a ghost matchmaking duties, and the third brings a dangerous curse to Middleton.

6. October Kiss (2015)

A wealthy widower hires a nanny to care for his children, and romance follows. It’s a familiar setup, but October Kiss wraps it in Halloween atmosphere, making it a comfortable choice for anyone who wants seasonal charm without a haunting.

Audiences have rewarded that approach with a 6.6 weighted IMDb average and a 6.8 unweighted average. Its most common individual rating is 7, putting it ahead of the lower-ranked costume balls and ghostly weddings.

5. 3 Bed, 2 Bath, 1 Ghost (2023)

Here’s a real-estate listing with one rather significant disclosure: A flapper-era ghost still has plans for her former home. Specifically, she wants the agent selling it to reunite with her ex. That gives 3 Bed, 2 Bath, 1 Ghost a clever twist on Hallmark’s usual romantic interference, even if it leans more supernatural than explicitly Halloween-themed.

Its IMDb weighted average jumps to 7.1 out of 10, with a 7.4 unweighted average and a most common score of 7.

4. Good Witch: Spellbound (2017)

The Good Witch movies take over the top of this list, starting with the series’ 10th feature. As All Hallows’ Eve approaches, Cassie and Sam must protect Middleton from an ancient evil curse. For viewers who like their Hallmark fall traditions with higher supernatural stakes, Spellbound delivers.

It has a 7.4 weighted average on IMDb, a 7.7 unweighted average, and a most common individual rating of 8.

3–1: Middleton claims the Halloween crown

The final three spots belong to Good Witch, but their order isn’t as straightforward as it first appears. Two movies share the same headline IMDb figures, so the finer details of their audience ratings make the difference.

3. Good Witch: Curse From a Rose (2019)

The 12th and final feature-length Good Witch story finds Middleton’s Halloween celebrations under threat once again. This time, Cassie’s former roommate Autumn arrives to cause trouble. Curse From a Rose has a 7.4 weighted IMDb average, a 7.8 unweighted average, and a most common individual rating of 8.

That’s a slight improvement over Spellbound, but not quite enough to take second place: Its second most common score is 7.

2. Good Witch: Tale of Two Hearts (2018)

Set between Spellbound and Curse From a Rose, this third Halloween-themed Good Witch feature mixes competitive fall drama with a mystery. On the surface, its IMDb numbers are identical to those of Curse From a Rose: a 7.4 weighted average, a 7.8 unweighted average, and a most common rating of 8.

The tiebreaker is its second most common rating, which is 10 out of 10. That gives Tale of Two Hearts the narrow edge.

1. Good Witch Halloween (2015)

The winner is also the first movie to take Good Witch fully into Halloween territory. The eighth film in the series remains its highest-rated Halloween outing, with a 7.6 weighted IMDb average, an 8.0 unweighted average, and a most common individual score of 10. So Good Witch Halloween isn’t just the obvious pick based on its title. Audience ratings back it up. Hallmark also made the film available to watch free on YouTube in September 2026, making it an especially easy place to start your seasonal marathon.

And the Halloween shelf is still growing. The Spirit of Halloween, starring Meghan Ory as a woman visited by three ghosts who help change her feelings about the holiday, is set to premiere on October 10, 2026. Until then, Middleton has the crown.