Former Packers Punter Jake Schum Joins Hallmark’s Finding Mr Christmas

There’s a new kind of holiday magic coming to the Hallmark Channel this season—and it’s got a little Lambeau swagger mixed in with all that mistletoe.

Former Green Bay Packers punter Jake Schum is trading his cleats for Christmas sweaters as one of ten contestants on the second season of *Finding Mr. Christmas*. Hallmark’s reality competition turns everyday men into leading men worthy of a holiday movie.

The show premieres October 27 at 7 p.m. on the Hallmark Channel and streams the next day on Hallmark+. It promises a festive blend of charm, competition, and a healthy dose of *Go Pack Go* spirit.

For Schum, who once booted footballs in front of tens of thousands at Lambeau Field, this new challenge might just be his most unexpected play yet.

From the Gridiron to the Garland

Jake Schum’s story is one of resilience, reinvention, and relentless energy. The 36-year-old former NFL punter, who played for the Packers in 2016 and 2017, is no stranger to pressure.

After being cut five times in four years before finally earning a roster spot with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in 2015, Schum knows what it means to fight for a dream. When the Packers picked him up in 2016, he seized the opportunity, punting his way through the NFC Championship game and earning a one-year extension.

A back injury sidelined him in 2017. Now, years later, he’s channeling that grit into a very different kind of arena—the Hallmark holiday universe.

Schum’s day job these days is far removed from the NFL lights. He owns and operates Gridiron Gateway Elite Training in Lake View, New York, working as a personal trainer and strength coach.

It’s the kind of career that keeps him grounded, but still competitive. When the opportunity to join *Finding Mr. Christmas* came around, Schum couldn’t resist.

In an Instagram post teasing his involvement, he admitted keeping the secret was tough—after all, how often does a former pro athlete get to compete for the chance to become a Hallmark leading man?

The Hallmark Holiday Hustle

*Finding Mr. Christmas* isn’t your typical dating or talent show. It’s a festive, tongue-in-cheek competition testing contestants on everything from wrapping gifts and untangling twinkle lights to acting out romantic holiday scenes—sometimes even on ice.

Hosted by Jonathan Bennett and judged by actress-comedian Melissa Peterman, the show blends humor, heart, and holiday hijinks into a format that’s pure Hallmark gold. Each week, one contestant is sent *home for the holidays* until a single man earns the coveted title of Mr. Christmas and a starring role in an upcoming Hallmark Countdown to Christmas movie.

Last season’s winner, Ezra Moreland, went on to star in *Happy Howlidays* alongside Jessica Lownes. That’s proof the competition can actually launch new Hallmark talent.

Schum’s bringing the same upbeat, team-first attitude that carried him through his football career. He describes his best leading man quality as his energy and positivity—he’s a “glass half full” guy who leads the way with enthusiasm.

Can a Punter Become a Prince of Christmas?

At first glance, the leap from punting footballs to perfecting a Hallmark kiss might seem like a stretch. But anyone familiar with Schum’s career knows he’s built for challenges like this.

His NFL journey was defined by perseverance—cut, signed, cut again, and finally making it to the pros through sheer determination. That same drive makes him a natural fit for a show that celebrates heart and hope as much as holiday cheer.

Hallmark’s audience loves a good redemption arc. The idea of a former athlete stepping into a world of scripted romance and snow-dusted charm is exactly the kind of feel-good story that keeps viewers tuning in year after year.

Schum’s background as a professional athlete brings a unique dynamic to the show. He’s used to performing under pressure, taking direction from coaches, and executing in front of massive audiences.

Now, he’ll just be swapping playbooks for scripts and stadium lights for Christmas tree lights.

Why Jake Schum Might Just Steal the Show

There’s something inherently likable about Schum’s underdog energy. He’s not a trained actor, but he’s got charisma, confidence, and a competitive streak that could make him a standout among the ten contestants.

His athletic background gives him an edge in the show’s more physical challenges—like obstacle courses and skating scenes. His upbeat personality makes him relatable and fun to watch.

Plus, his family-man image and real-world humility fit perfectly into Hallmark’s wholesome brand of storytelling.

• Experience under pressure: Years in the NFL taught Schum how to stay cool when the spotlight’s on.
• Physical readiness: As a trainer, he’s in top shape for any challenge the show throws at him.
• Positive energy: His “glass half full” attitude is tailor-made for Hallmark’s feel-good vibe.
• Authentic charm: Viewers love contestants who bring sincerity—and Schum has that in spades.

The Magic of “Finding Mr. Christmas”

Part of what makes *Finding Mr. Christmas* a hit is its mix of humor, heart, and holiday spectacle. It’s not just about who looks best in a Santa hat—it’s about who can embody the spirit of a Hallmark hero.

Contestants have to show they can be romantic, funny, kind, and just a little bit goofy, all while maintaining that signature Hallmark warmth. The show’s lighthearted competitions—like wrapping presents under pressure or acting out on-ice love scenes—are designed to test both skill and spirit.

With Jonathan Bennett leading the festivities, viewers can expect plenty of laughter. Bennett, known for his own Hallmark roles and his sense of humor, keeps the energy high while Melissa Peterman brings sharp wit and warmth to her role as lead judge.

Together, they create a dynamic that’s part holiday pageant, part comedy hour, and all Christmas cheer.

Hallmark’s Countdown to Christmas Legacy

For Hallmark fans, *Finding Mr. Christmas* is more than just a competition—it’s a gateway into the network’s most beloved season. The winner doesn’t just get bragging rights; he earns a starring role in one of Hallmark’s upcoming *Countdown to Christmas* films, a dream gig for anyone hoping to become a household name in cozy holiday entertainment.

Last year’s winner, Ezra Moreland, proved that the show is a legitimate launching pad, and viewers are eager to see who will follow in his footsteps.

With Schum in the mix, the show gains a new kind of appeal—one that bridges the worlds of sports and entertainment. Packers fans will undoubtedly be cheering him on, while Hallmark loyalists will be curious to see how an NFL alum handles the mistletoe moments.

It’s a crossover that feels fresh, fun, and full of festive promise.

What’s Next for Jake Schum?

Jake Schum’s leap into *Finding Mr. Christmas* is a wild new chapter after his NFL days. Whether he wins or not, it’s just fun to see him try something totally different.

It’s honestly refreshing—reinvention doesn’t have to be a drag. Sometimes, the best stuff happens when you’re not even chasing it.

Here, Schum gets to show off more than just his athletic side. There’s a bit more heart, more personality, and a lot more connection on display.

And hey, if he pulls off that classic Hallmark kiss? Maybe he’s the next big face of holiday movies. Stranger things have happened.

With the holidays creeping up, *Finding Mr. Christmas* feels like it could be one of those surprise hits. It’s got festive energy, some genuine competition, and a dash of transformation—what’s not to like?

Packers fans, Hallmark devotees, or anyone who roots for the underdog might want to tune in. Schum’s journey from NFL punter to possible Christmas prince is the kind of story that, honestly, just makes you smile on a cold night.