Hallmark’s Fall 2025 Movie Lineup: A Star-Studded Extravaganza with Faces from HTGAWM, S.H.I.E.L.D., and More
Hallmark Channel is gearing up to sweep you off your feet again with its “Fall Into Love” programming this September. The lineup’s pretty packed, honestly—three Hallmark+ favorites making their cable debut and two brand-new movies that promise romance, a bit of mystery, and those warm fuzzy feelings.
You’ll spot familiar faces like Jonathan Bennett, B.J. Britt, Elizabeth Henstridge, and Andrew Walker. These films are shaping up to be your next autumn go-tos. So, maybe grab your calendar and get ready to dive into Hallmark’s cozy September world?
Find the best accommodations and airfares
Check availability at 5* hotels, guest houses and apartments rated "superb" or "exceptional" by visitors just like you.
NO RESERVATION FEES
CHECK AVAILABILITY FOR YOUR DATES HERE
Table of Contents
Hallmark+ Brings Back Beloved Favorites
This September, Hallmark Channel is rolling out three popular Hallmark+ movies on cable for the first time. The trilogy, called The Groomsmen, includes First Look, Second Chances, and Last Dance.
Each movie brings its own spin on love and relationships. If you’re a Hallmark fan, these are probably already on your radar.
First Look – A Romance Not Quite What the Doctor Ordered
Premiering Saturday, September 6 at 8/7c, First Look stars B.J. Britt, Heather Hemmens, Jonathan Bennett, and Tyler Hynes. The story centers on a cautious pediatrician (Britt) and an overseas doctor (Hemmens) who meet at a wedding in Philadelphia.
Sparks fly, but long distance, family drama, and friends get in the way. It’s classic Hallmark, but with a few extra bumps in the road.
- Premiere Date: Saturday, September 6 at 8/7c
- Starring: B.J. Britt, Heather Hemmens, Jonathan Bennett, Tyler Hynes
- Synopsis: A cautious pediatrician and an overseas doctor meet at a wedding, facing challenges that test their budding romance.
Second Chances – Love Blossoms in Greece
Next up is Second Chances, airing Saturday, September 13 at 8/7c. B.J. Britt, Jonathan Bennett, Tyler Hynes, and Alexander Lincoln headline this one.
This time, Danny (Bennett) finally gets up the nerve to tell his best friend (Lincoln) how he feels—right as he’s asked to be best man at his wedding in Greece. The timing? Well, it’s complicated.
- Premiere Date: Saturday, September 13 at 8/7c
- Starring: B.J. Britt, Jonathan Bennett, Tyler Hynes, Alexander Lincoln
- Synopsis: Danny admits his romantic feelings for his best friend when asked to be the best man at his wedding in Greece.
Last Dance – An Unexpected Italian Love Story
The trilogy wraps up with Last Dance on Saturday, September 20 at 8/7c. You’ll see B.J. Britt, Jonathan Bennett, Tyler Hynes, and Elena Rusconi in this one.
Jackson (Hynes) moves to Italy to be closer to his daughter. But then he meets Gabriella (Rusconi), who runs a cozy little cafe, and—thanks to some meddling friends—he might just find himself falling in love again.
- Premiere Date: Saturday, September 20 at 8/7c
- Starring: B.J. Britt, Jonathan Bennett, Tyler Hynes, Elena Rusconi
- Synopsis: Jackson moves to Italy to be near his daughter and finds a second chance at love with a cafe owner.
New Releases to Keep You on the Edge of Your Seat
Besides the Hallmark+ favorites, Hallmark Channel is premiering two brand-new films this September. These promise a little more mystery and adventure—because why not shake things up?
Mystery Island: House Rules – A Game Gone Wrong
Premiering Sunday, September 14 at 8/7c, Mystery Island: House Rules stars Elizabeth Henstridge and Charlie Weber. The movie follows the buzz of Mystery Island, with expansion plans in the works.
The Island team meets up with their Mystery Mountain counterparts for what’s supposed to be a friendly murder game. Of course, things get very real, very fast, when someone actually turns up dead right in front of everyone.
- Premiere Date: Sunday, September 14 at 8/7c
- Starring: Elizabeth Henstridge, Charlie Weber
- Synopsis: A friendly murder game turns deadly when a real murder occurs in plain sight.
Adventures in Love & Birding – A Misunderstood Assignment
Adventures in Love & Birding closes out the new releases, premiering Saturday, September 27 at 8/7c. Rachel Boston and Andrew Walker star in this one.
It’s about a single mom (Boston) who agrees to team up with a bird enthusiast (Walker) during a birding tournament. But here’s the twist: she totally misunderstands and tells everyone she’s his girlfriend, not just a teammate—cue the awkward, funny, and maybe a little sweet moments.
- Premiere Date: Saturday, September 27 at 8/7c
- Starring: Rachel Boston, Andrew Walker
- Synopsis: A single mom agrees to be a bird enthusiast’s partner during a birding tournament but misunderstands the assignment, leading to comedic and romantic complications.
Get Ready to Fall in Love This September!
Hallmark Channel’s “Fall Into Love” lineup is looking pretty irresistible this year. There’s a mix of romantic comedies, heartfelt dramas, and even a few mysteries tossed in for good measure.
Honestly, there’s something here for just about everyone. September evenings might just feel a bit more magical with these stories and familiar faces lighting up the screen.
Grab some popcorn and settle in on the couch. If you’re anything like me, you won’t want to miss these premieres—so maybe go ahead and set those DVRs.
Christmas Market Closures
Due to econonic conditions and tariffs, some Christmas Markets may cancel their events due to lack of vendors. If you are aware of a closed market,or find errors on a listing or an image, please reach out on our Contact Us page so that we may update this post.
