Jonathan Bennett Reveals 10 New Hunks for Finding Mr Christmas Season 2

It’s officially the most wonderful—and thirstiest—time of the year! Hallmark Channel is back to sprinkle a little extra glitter on your holiday season with the return of Finding Mr. Christmas, the reality competition that’s quickly become a festive favorite.

Season 2 promises even more charm, abs, and yuletide spirit as ten dazzling new contestants compete for the chance to become Hallmark’s next leading man. Hosted by Jonathan Bennett, the beloved Mean Girls alum and Hallmark’s trailblazer for LGBTQ+ representation, this season is shaping up to be the gayest, glitziest, and honestly, most heartwarming holiday event of the year.

From cozy sweaters to shirtless selfies, these guys are ready to sleigh their way into your heart—and maybe even into a Hallmark movie near you. I mean, who could resist?

The Return of Holiday Magic: Hallmark’s Inclusive Glow-Up

When Hallmark first launched Finding Mr. Christmas, it was a bold move—a blend of wholesome holiday charm and reality TV glamour. With its debut season melting hearts across America, season 2 arrives with even more sparkle, diversity, and emotional depth.

The show’s mission goes beyond just finding the next handsome face. It’s about redefining what love looks like on television, especially during the holidays.

At the center of it all is Jonathan Bennett, who’s become a beacon for inclusivity on the Hallmark Channel. Having starred in titles like The Christmas House, The Christmas House 2: Deck the Halls, Christmas on Cherry Lane, Season’s Greetings from Cherry Lane, Happy Howlidays, and The Holiday Sitter, Bennett’s helped usher in a new era of storytelling.

Now, LGBTQ+ love stories shine just as brightly as the twinkling lights on a Christmas tree. His passion for representation has reshaped the network’s image, proving that love, in all its forms, belongs at the heart of Hallmark’s holiday lineup.

Jonathan Bennett’s Mission: Love Without Limits

Bennett’s role isn’t just that of a charming host; he’s a visionary who wants everyone to see themselves in the magic of Hallmark’s seasonal stories. As he’s shared in interviews, his goal has always been to quiet the critics and amplify the joy of authentic representation.

Over the past five years, Hallmark’s evolved from a traditional, heteronormative brand into a more inclusive platform where our love looks just like yours. That transformation is due in large part to Bennett’s persistence and passion.

For viewers who grew up watching Hallmark’s cozy romances, seeing same-sex couples find their happy endings on screen has been nothing short of groundbreaking. The network’s willingness to embrace that change—and celebrate it through shows like Finding Mr. Christmas—marks a turning point in holiday entertainment.

It’s not just about who gets the mistletoe kiss anymore; it’s about who gets to be seen, cherished, and celebrated. That feels like progress, doesn’t it?

Meet the Holiday Hunks: Ten Contestants, One Christmas Crown

Now, let’s unwrap what everyone’s been waiting for—the ten heartthrobs competing for the coveted title of Mr. Christmas. Each contestant brings his own brand of charm, talent, and festive flair to the competition.

From models to musicians, actors to athletes, this year’s lineup is as diverse as it is dazzling. They’ll face a series of acting challenges, holiday-themed tasks, and charisma tests to see who really has the charisma, uniqueness, nerve, and talent to lead a Hallmark holiday movie.

• Drake – A 27-year-old model and social media manager from Denver who’s mastered the art of the perfect thirst trap. His Instagram feed could probably make Santa blush.
• Robbie Simpson – An out actor and theater director from NYC who grew up watching Hallmark movies with his mom. Now, he’s living the dream and representing queer visibility on national television.
• Angel – A 38-year-old Venezuelan-born model and actor raised in North Carolina, known for his role on BET’s First Wives Club. His charisma is as warm as a holiday hearth.
• Gabe – Originally from Wyoming and now based in Los Angeles, this 32-year-old model knows how to strike a pose that could stop Santa’s sleigh mid-flight.
• Coach – A 36-year-old personal trainer and former NFL player from Upstate New York who once played for the NY Jets and Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Expect him to bring discipline, drive, and a whole lot of holiday heat.
• The Lake Tahoe Trainer – At 34, this fitness expert and model proves that snow isn’t the only thing that’s sculpted in the mountains.
• The Long Island Actor – A 33-year-old personal trainer and performer who’s ready to flex both his muscles and his acting chops.
• The LA Fitness Enthusiast – At 32, this model and actor embodies California holiday vibes—sun, surf, and sleigh bells.
• The Ohio Photographer – A 30-year-old creative who knows how to frame a moment—and himself—in the best light possible.
• The San Diego Musician – At 37, this artist knows how to hit all the right notes, both on stage and under the mistletoe.

Competition Meets Christmas Spirit

Throughout the season, these ten hopefuls will face a variety of challenges designed to test not just their looks, but their heart and authenticity. From reenacting classic Hallmark scenes to creating their own heartfelt holiday moments, each episode promises laughter, tears, and plenty of swoon-worthy surprises.

The ultimate prize? A starring role in an upcoming Hallmark holiday movie—a dream come true for anyone who’s ever imagined themselves falling in love in a snow-covered small town.

But beyond the competition, Finding Mr. Christmas is about connection. It’s about celebrating the joy of community, the beauty of vulnerability, and the power of representation.

Whether it’s a contestant sharing his coming-out story or bonding over shared family traditions, the show captures what the holidays are truly about: love, acceptance, and belonging. Isn’t that the best part?

Why Finding Mr. Christmas Matters More Than Ever

In a world that often feels divided, Hallmark’s decision to keep expanding its definition of love is both refreshing and, honestly, overdue. The network’s evolution reflects a broader cultural shift—one that recognizes that holiday magic belongs to everyone.

By showcasing queer contestants, diverse backgrounds, and authentic love stories, Finding Mr. Christmas sends a powerful message: everyone deserves their own Hallmark ending.

Bennett’s leadership has been instrumental in this transformation. His advocacy ensures that the stories told on Hallmark aren’t just picture-perfect—they’re real, inclusive, and deeply human.

As he’s pointed out, the negative chatter about representation has faded because audiences are connecting with the humanity behind the stories. Love, after all, is universal.

Streaming, Scheduling, and Staying Cozy

Fans can tune in to watch Finding Mr. Christmas every Monday at 8/7c on the Hallmark Channel, with next-day streaming available on Hallmark Plus. Whether you’re snuggled up with cocoa or scrolling through social media, you won’t want to miss a single episode.

The show invites viewers to cheer, swoon, and maybe even shed a few happy tears as these ten contestants chase their Christmas dreams. That’s the kind of holiday spirit I can get behind.

And if you’re looking for even more behind-the-scenes fun, Queerty’s coverage has you covered—from exclusive photos to cheeky commentary that will keep your holiday spirits bright. Because let’s face it: nothing says season’s greetings quite like a lineup of handsome hopefuls in Santa hats.

The Gift That Keeps on Giving

As *Finding Mr. Christmas* rolls into its second season, you can tell it’s more than a simple competition. It’s really become a celebration of progress, pride, and passion.

The show proves holiday traditions can totally change and still keep their heart. Jonathan Bennett’s back at the helm, and there’s a fresh wave of stars waiting to step into the spotlight.

Hallmark’s future? It’s looking pretty merry, bright, and honestly, more inclusive than ever.

Grab a cozy blanket and maybe a peppermint latte, if that’s your thing. Get ready to fall in love with the holidays all over again.

This season, *Finding Mr. Christmas* isn’t just about picking the next Hallmark hunk. It’s about the joy, hope, and representation that make the holidays actually feel magical.