Jonathan Bennett Teases Hotter Wilder Heartfelt Finding Mr Christmas Season 2

Hallmark Channel is decking the halls early this year with the return of its hit reality competition series *Finding Mr. Christmas*. Host Jonathan Bennett is promising that season two will be bigger, bolder, and way more festive than before.

The show’s set to premiere on October 27, 2025. Once again, ten dazzlingly handsome contestants will compete for the ultimate Hallmark dream — a starring role in a Christmas movie.

This time, Bennett says everything’s been *dialed up*. With returning co-host Melissa Peterman and a lineup of familiar Hallmark faces, the new season is aiming for more heart, humor, and holiday heat.

The Return of Hallmark’s Most Handsome Holiday Hunt

When *Finding Mr. Christmas* first premiered, people fell for its mix of reality competition and Hallmark heart. The concept — finding the next leading man for a Christmas movie — just clicked with fans who love the network’s signature romance and sparkle.

Now, as season two gets ready to launch, Bennett says the formula’s the same, but the intensity’s up. “Season one was so good,” he told EntertainmentNow, “we didn’t need to fix anything — we just turned it up a notch.”

That means more charm, more emotion, and, yeah, more *hunkiness*. Bennett teased that the new cast might just redefine what it means to be a Hallmark heartthrob.

From former NFL players to fitness models and doting dads, this lineup promises to make audiences swoon. “We found hunks,” Bennett said, grinning, but he’s clear that it’s not just about looks — it’s about men who really embody the Hallmark spirit, both on and off camera.

Meet the Men Competing for the Mistletoe Crown

This season’s cast is a mix of charisma and compassion. Among the standout contestants:

• Jake Schum – A former NFL player whose athleticism and charm feel like a perfect fit for Hallmark’s wholesome hero vibe.
• Marcus Brodie – A professional model and fitness enthusiast with a warm personality to match his sculpted physique.
• Davey Fisher – A personal trainer and devoted father, whose down-to-earth nature and big heart could melt even the iciest winter night.

Bennett hinted that one of the contestants “looks like a Disney prince come to life.” Viewers probably won’t be disappointed by the eye candy this season.

But, as always, the real magic is in how these men connect — not just with the judges, but with each other.

Brotherhood Beneath the Tinsel

Unlike most competition shows, *Finding Mr. Christmas* thrives on warmth and vulnerability. Hallmark’s brand is all about connection, and Bennett says that carries over behind the scenes.

“We let the guys just talk and open up,” he explained, describing how real friendships started to bloom among the contestants. What began as a competition quickly turned into a brotherhood.

In true Hallmark style, these contestants didn’t just compete — they cared. Bennett shared that the group still keeps in touch, showing up for birthdays and celebrating milestones together.

Kindness as a Competitive Edge

Most reality shows love drama, but *Finding Mr. Christmas* goes the other way. Contestants are encouraged to show kindness, empathy, and real emotional openness — the stuff of any true Hallmark leading man.

The show rewards authenticity over arrogance, and vulnerability over vanity. Expect more touching moments this season, as the men share personal stories and support each other through the wild challenges.

Bennett thinks this focus on heart is what sets the show apart. “We’re not just looking for someone who can act,” he said. “We’re looking for someone who can make audiences feel something real.”

Dialing Up the Festive Fun

No competition is complete without a few curveballs, and Bennett promises this year’s challenges will push the contestants more than ever. His third big promise to fans? “Things are gonna get wild.”

The new season brings in more intense and physical tasks to test the men’s acting chops, stamina, creativity, and composure under pressure. The challenges have been amped up to be more dynamic and unpredictable.

Expect festive face-offs that combine physical endurance with plenty of holiday flair. From snowy obstacle courses to impromptu acting scenes right out of a Hallmark movie, each episode will show off the contestants’ versatility in ways you might not expect.

Bennett says some challenges even mirror real-life Hallmark set situations — like working with animals or learning lines on the fly. Sounds like chaos, but that’s half the fun.

Acting Under the Mistletoe

The acting parts of the competition have changed, too. Contestants will step into authentic Hallmark-style scenarios and try to deliver heartfelt performances on the spot.

The goal? Find a guy who doesn’t just look the part, but can *live* it — someone who could step onto a Hallmark set next to Ashley Williams and feel right at home.

For Bennett, that’s what makes a winner. “Hallmark stars aren’t just good actors,” he said. “They’re kind, funny, charming, and have huge hearts.”

Why Fans Can’t Wait for Season Two

With its blend of romance, humor, and holiday spirit, *Finding Mr. Christmas* has become a seasonal staple for Hallmark fans. The show taps into everything viewers love about the network — cozy charm and emotional storytelling — while adding a fresh twist with its reality competition format.

For longtime fans, it’s about watching ordinary men transform into potential Hallmark heroes. For newcomers, it’s a chance to experience the joy and wholesomeness that the brand is famous for.

And for Jonathan Bennett, it’s just another shot at spreading the message that love, laughter, and kindness never go out of style — especially at the holidays. Who could argue with that?

When and Where to Watch

Mark your calendars: *Finding Mr. Christmas* season two premieres on Hallmark Channel on October 27, 2025, at 8 p.m. Eastern.

Each episode drops on Hallmark+ the next day, so you don’t have to stress if you miss the live broadcast.

Whether you’re in it for the competition, the camaraderie, or just the Christmas vibes, there’s something about this season that feels extra magical.

As Bennett himself might say—yeah, the holidays just got a whole lot hotter.