Kevin McGarry Wins Favorite Hallmark Actor of 2025

The Hallmark fandom showed up in a massive way as Just Jared officially closed its Favorite Hallmark Channel Actor of 2025 poll. The results delivered drama, devotion, and a landslide victory that few can argue with.

With nearly 300,000 votes cast, this wasn’t just a casual popularity contest. It was a full-blown fan movement that crowned one familiar face as the undisputed king of cozy romance television.

From runaway winners to surprising placements, the final tally reveals a lot about who truly captured hearts over the past year.

The Poll That Took Hallmark Fans by Storm

Just Jared’s annual Hallmark poll has become a barometer for fandom power. 2025 proved to be one of its most competitive years yet.

With unlimited voting and a randomized ballot to keep things fair, fans rallied hard behind their favorites. The sheer volume of votes shows just how invested audiences are in the actors who define the Hallmark brand.

This year’s poll featured a who’s who of Hallmark leading men, from romantic comedy staples to long-running series favorites. While many names were expected to perform well, the final rankings made one thing clear: one actor stood far above the rest.

How the Voting Worked

The poll allowed fans to vote as many times as they wished until it officially closed on January 5, 2026 at 3 p.m. ET. That strategy paid off, with nearly 294,000 total votes logged.

• Unlimited voting fueled passionate fan campaigns
• Randomized answer order helped prevent automated manipulation
• Broad eligibility included actors from recent Hallmark films and series

With all those variables, only the most devoted fandoms could push their favorite stars to the top.

Kevin McGarry’s Landslide Victory

There was no suspense at the top. Kevin McGarry dominated the poll from start to finish, earning the crown as Just Jared’s Favorite Hallmark Channel Actor of 2025.

His victory wasn’t narrow—it was overwhelming. By the time voting closed, McGarry had over 123,000 votes, accounting for more than 42 percent of the total.

In a field this crowded, that kind of margin is extraordinary.

Why Kevin McGarry Won Big

McGarry’s appeal is rooted in consistency and emotional resonance. As a fan favorite on When Calls the Heart, he’s cultivated a loyal audience that shows up every time it counts.

His performances balance charm, vulnerability, and old-fashioned romantic appeal—a combination that really defines Hallmark’s core brand.

• Total Votes: 123,905
• Percentage of Vote: 42.16%
• Rank: First Place

Tyler Hynes Secures a Strong Second Place

Coming in second was Tyler Hynes, another Hallmark heavyweight with a fiercely devoted fanbase. While he couldn’t match McGarry’s runaway numbers, Hynes still delivered an impressive showing.

With more than 56,000 votes, Hynes claimed nearly 20 percent of the total. His popularity remains rock solid.

The Power of the Hynes Fandom

Tyler Hynes has built a reputation for playing layered, emotionally complex characters. He often brings a slightly edgier or more modern energy to Hallmark storytelling.

That distinction has helped him cultivate fans who are loyal and highly organized when it comes to voting.

• Total Votes: 56,674
• Percentage of Vote: 19.28%
• Rank: Second Place

Niall Matter Rounds Out the Top Three

Claiming third place was Niall Matter, whose steady presence across Hallmark projects has earned him lasting goodwill from viewers. The gap between second and third was notable, but Matter still posted numbers many actors would envy.

With over 31,000 votes, he captured more than 10 percent of the overall tally.

A Quietly Consistent Favorite

Matter’s appeal lies in his reliability. Whether anchoring romantic dramas or ensemble casts, he delivers performances that feel sincere and grounded.

• Total Votes: 31,043
• Percentage of Vote: 10.56%
• Rank: Third Place

The Mid-Tier Finishers and Fanbase Surprises

Beyond the top three, the poll revealed a tightly packed middle tier. Just a few thousand votes separated multiple actors.

These rankings highlight how broad and diverse Hallmark fandom has become. Actors like Warren Christie, Chris McNally, and Andrew Walker each pulled in respectable numbers, reflecting steady fan engagement even if they didn’t dominate the conversation.

Notable Middle Rankings

• Warren Christie: 9,639 votes (3.28%)
• Chris McNally: 9,418 votes (3.2%)
• Andrew Walker: 7,706 votes (2.62%)
• Peter Mooney: 6,775 votes (2.31%)
• Brennan Elliott: 6,401 votes (2.18%)

These placements show that while the top tier may be dominated by a few names, the Hallmark bench remains deep with talent fans are eager to support.

What the Results Say About Hallmark’s Future

The overwhelming participation in this poll speaks volumes about the health of the Hallmark brand. Nearly 294,000 votes is not just impressive—it’s a signal that viewers remain emotionally invested in the stars who bring these stories to life.

Kevin McGarry’s decisive win suggests that long-running series and character continuity still matter deeply to audiences. At the same time, strong showings from actors across the roster show there’s room for both legacy favorites and newer faces.

A Network Powered by Fandom

As Hallmark looks ahead, these results offer a bit of a roadmap. Fans reward consistency and emotional authenticity.

They also seem to love stars who stick around and actually engage with them year after year. If this poll says anything, it’s that the network’s leading men aren’t just actors—they’re brands, with passionate followings who are ready to mobilize at a moment’s notice.

And really, if 2025 taught us anything, it’s this: when Hallmark fans vote, they vote loud.