Lacey Chabert Shines in Hallmark’s New Movie Shes Making a List

Hallmark Channel is back at it, stirring up a little holiday movie magic with its latest original, She’s Making a List. Starring fan favorites Lacey Chabert and Andrew Walker, this one’s got all the makings of a cozy Christmas escape—heart, humor, and just enough wonder to keep you watching.

The story centers on Isabel, a top inspector for the Naughty or Nice Group. She’s got the very important (and, let’s be honest, slightly overwhelming) job of creating Santa’s list for the year.

Things get complicated when her work brings her face to face with a mischievous kid and his charming, widowed dad. Suddenly, Isabel’s not so sure if she should stick to the rules or trust her heart instead.

With a fresh spin on a classic Christmas conundrum, She’s Making a List is already shaping up to be one of the most buzzed-about holiday premieres of 2025. I mean, who doesn’t love a little rule-breaking in the name of love?

The Magic Behind Hallmark’s Latest Holiday Hit

Hallmark’s whole thing is comfort and feel-good vibes, and She’s Making a List fits right in. The film debuts Saturday, December 6 at 8/7c on Hallmark Channel, so you might want to have your cocoa and blanket ready.

If you’ve followed Chabert and Walker over the years, seeing them together feels like an early Christmas present. They’re basically Hallmark royalty at this point, and their chemistry is bound to bring that extra spark.

At the heart of the film, there’s this question: What happens when the rules of Christmas meet the messiness of real life? Isabel’s job is to decide if kids make the cut for Santa’s Naughty or Nice list.

But after she meets 11-year-old Charlie and his dad Jason, Isabel’s carefully ordered world starts to wobble. The story weaves together love, compassion, and the courage to maybe, just maybe, write your own rules.

Streaming Options for Every Kind of Viewer

Honestly, it’s never been easier to catch a Hallmark premiere. Whether you’re streaming or sticking with cable, there are plenty of ways to watch She’s Making a List live or whenever you get a chance.

• Fubo: Usually known for sports, but it’s got over 100 live TV channels—including Hallmark. New folks can try a free trial and get $30 off the first month, so you’re looking at $84.99 to start, minus the discount.
• DIRECTV: Four streaming packages begin at $89.99, and there’s a 5-day free trial plus a $40 discount for new users. That makes it as low as $49 for month one.
• Philo: If you want something affordable, Philo’s a solid pick. It’s just $33 a month for 70+ channels, Hallmark included, and you’ll get content from HBO Max and discovery+ thrown in.
• Sling: Sling TV’s got day, week, and weekend passes starting at $4.99. Regular plans are $45.99 a month after the discounts run out.

With all these streaming choices and free trials, nobody’s missing out on the holiday cheer. Honestly, dipping your toes into Hallmark’s wintery world has never been less of a commitment.

The Story That Redefines the Naughty or Nice List

Santa’s list is a Christmas classic, but She’s Making a List gives it a clever update. Instead of elves with quill pens, the film features the Naughty or Nice Group—a consulting firm running the show with data and algorithms.

Isabel, played by Chabert, is their top inspector. She’s known for her laser focus and dedication, rating kids with a super-precise formula to figure out their niceness quotient.

But things get interesting when she’s sent to assess Charlie Duncan, an 11-year-old who’s got a real knack for mischief. Charlie’s dad Jason (that’s Walker) is a widower, just trying to keep the holiday spirit alive for his son.

The more time Isabel spends with them, the more she starts to wonder if life—and Christmas—can really be measured by numbers. Her journey from rule-follower to rule-breaker is where the movie’s heart really beats.

A Classic Hallmark Romance with a Fresh Twist

If you love Hallmark’s usual style, this one won’t disappoint. The movie checks all the boxes: snowy small towns, warm confessions, and those classic holiday traditions.

Chabert gives Isabel her signature warmth, while Walker brings a quiet sincerity to Jason. Together, they make the romance feel sweet and, honestly, a little more real than you’d expect.

This film stands out for its take on balance—trying to find that middle ground between duty and desire, logic and love. It’s a gentle reminder that even Santa’s helpers need a little magic sometimes, don’t they?

Why This Movie Is a Must-Watch This Holiday Season

Hallmark drops a bunch of holiday movies every year, but She’s Making a List is already getting attention as a standout for 2025. Chabert and Walker together, the clever premise, and a little more emotional depth than usual—it’s more than just another cozy romance.

The film also touches on how technology and tradition mix in today’s world. The Naughty or Nice Group brings in the efficiency of the digital age, but Isabel’s story is about finding her way back to real connection.

It’s a quiet reminder that Christmas isn’t about data points. It’s about kindness, empathy, and love—something you can’t really measure, right?

Other Holiday Highlights to Stream

If you’re up for a weekend holiday marathon, there’s no shortage of options. Along with She’s Making a List, you’ve got new releases like A Motown Christmas, Kevin Costner Presents: The First Christmas, and the second season of Disney+’s Percy Jackson and the Olympians.

Each one brings its own flavor to the season—family adventures, musical moments, and more. There’s really something for everyone, whether you’re in it for the laughs or the feels.

So, whether you’re with family or just treating yourself to a quiet night in, She’s Making a List is a pretty great way to start the holidays. It’s got heart, laughs, and that Hallmark charm that keeps us coming back every year—even if we don’t always admit it.

Final Thoughts: A New Classic in the Making

*She’s Making a List* brings an enchanting storyline and a pair of leads you can’t help but root for. There’s a message tucked in there that goes way past the usual holiday fluff.

It nudges you to look past labels and, honestly, to let go of that urge for everything to be just-so. Sometimes the most meaningful gifts show up where you least expect them.

Isabel’s whole journey—trying to juggle her responsibilities and her heart—feels relatable. It’s a reminder that the real magic of Christmas isn’t about perfection. It’s about showing up, even when things get messy.

December 6 is the date, so maybe jot it down? Grab some snacks, get comfy, and let *She’s Making a List* pull you in for a couple hours of warmth and wonder.

With Lacey Chabert and Andrew Walker sharing the screen, you just get the feeling it’ll be a Christmas you’ll want to remember.