Lori Loughlin Comeback Hopes Rise for When Calls the Heart

Fans of *When Calls the Heart* are buzzing again as rumors swirl about Lori Loughlin possibly returning to the beloved Hallmark series. The actress, who played the warm-hearted Abigail Stanton, left the show in 2019 after her involvement in the college admissions scandal.

Now, years later, her former co-stars and even the show’s co-creator are dropping hints that a comeback could be in the works. Hallmark says there are no official talks, but whispers of *good conversations* behind the scenes have reignited hope among Hearties that Abigail might stroll through Hope Valley again.

Erin Krakow, the show’s leading lady, hasn’t been shy about her feelings—she’d *love* to see her friend return. Could redemption, both on-screen and off, really be in the cards?

The Heart of Hope Valley Still Misses Abigail Stanton

It’s been five years since Lori Loughlin’s Abigail Stanton left *When Calls the Heart*, and honestly, the void remains. Abigail was a pillar—strong, compassionate, a leader—someone who really embodied the spirit of Hope Valley.

For many, her absence is felt in every season. Erin Krakow, who plays Elizabeth Thatcher, recently told *Us Weekly* that she’s been wishing for Loughlin’s return *for years and years.*

Krakow’s words were genuine and personal. She called herself both a *fan* and a *friend* of Loughlin, and you could feel the affection in her comments.

This connection between cast members has always been a big part of the show’s appeal. Krakow’s open support has definitely fired up fan enthusiasm.

Hallmark’s Official Stance: Not in Talks—Yet

Despite all the buzz, Hallmark Media insists there are no formal discussions about Loughlin’s return. In a statement to *People*, the network confirmed they’re *not in talks* with her about reprising Abigail.

Still, fans won’t let go of the idea, especially after co-creator Brian Bird hinted that there are *good conversations happening* around the topic. Bird’s remarks have just added fuel to the fire.

On the *Heart to Hearties* podcast, he said that while nothing’s guaranteed, there’s ongoing dialogue. He also gave a little update on Loughlin herself—she’s *doing really good* and seems to have found some peace after all the legal drama.

His optimism, paired with Krakow’s support, has viewers wondering if Hallmark might eventually change its mind.

The Scandal That Shook Hollywood—and Hope Valley

Loughlin’s exit in 2019 came at the height of the college admissions scandal that rocked Hollywood. She and her husband, Mossimo Giannulli, were accused of paying for their daughters, Olivia Jade and Bella, to get into USC under false pretenses.

The couple pleaded guilty to conspiracy and wire fraud charges. Loughlin served two months in prison, Giannulli did five. The fallout was huge—not just for their reputations, but also for Loughlin’s relationship with Hallmark.

For the *When Calls the Heart* community, the loss was tough. Abigail Stanton had been a cornerstone, and her sudden exit left fans heartbroken.

The writers handled her departure gently, saying Abigail left Hope Valley to care for her ailing mother. That storyline left the door open for a possible return—a choice that feels more meaningful now.

Life After the Scandal: A New Chapter for Lori Loughlin

Since serving her sentence, Loughlin’s kept a pretty low profile, focusing on rebuilding her life. Reports suggest she and Giannulli have recently separated after nearly 28 years of marriage, which is another huge shift for her.

Those close to her say Loughlin’s found some peace and resilience. Co-creator Brian Bird described her as being in *a much better place* than during the height of the scandal.

Her quiet comeback started in 2021 when she played Abigail again in *When Hope Calls: A Country Christmas*, a spinoff on GAC Family. Fans welcomed her back with open arms, proving many are ready to forgive and move forward.

If Hallmark follows suit, it could be one of the most talked-about redemption arcs on TV in recent years.

Why Fans Want Abigail Back

The loyalty of *When Calls the Heart* fans—Hearties—is pretty legendary. They’ve stood by the show for over a decade, loving its themes of love, forgiveness, and faith.

For a lot of people, Abigail Stanton is the heart of those values. Her leadership, compassion, and ability to overcome adversity made her a fan favorite.

Bringing Abigail back would thrill longtime viewers and reinforce the show’s message: everyone deserves a second chance. Brian Bird summed it up well: *what better place for second chances than Hope Valley?*

It’s a sentiment that really resonates, especially considering Loughlin’s real-life journey.

The Power of Forgiveness in Hollywood

Hollywood loves a comeback, but Lori Loughlin’s return to Hallmark would be especially symbolic. The industry has a weird relationship with forgiveness—some stars bounce back instantly, others take years.

In Loughlin’s case, the conversation has shifted from outrage to empathy. A lot of fans feel she’s paid her dues and deserves a shot at rebuilding her career.

Erin Krakow’s public support just adds to that feeling. By saying she wants Loughlin back, she’s kind of given fans permission to hope again.

And if *When Calls the Heart* is really about redemption, then bringing Abigail home would be the ultimate proof.

Could Hope Valley See a Reunion Soon?

Hallmark’s official stance might be cautious, but insiders say the conversation isn’t over. The network has a history of listening to fans, and *When Calls the Heart* is still one of its biggest hits.

If enough people push for it, maybe Hallmark will reconsider. The show’s creators have left the door open—literally and figuratively—for Abigail’s return.

Can you imagine the emotional impact of seeing Abigail walk back into Hope Valley, greeted by friends old and new? It’d be cathartic, honestly, not just for the characters but for the audience, too.

A storyline about forgiveness, healing, and community fits right into what *When Calls the Heart* does best.

What Comes Next

For now, fans will just have to wait and see if those *good conversations* Brian Bird talked about actually turn into something real. Erin Krakow’s heartfelt words keep echoing through the fandom, reminding everyone what makes *When Calls the Heart* so special.

Whether Hallmark decides to take the leap or not, one thing’s obvious: the love for Abigail Stanton—and for Lori Loughlin herself—hasn’t really faded. As the show gears up for future seasons, there’s one big question hanging in the air. Will Hope Valley open its doors to one of its most cherished residents again?