Paul Campbell and Tyler Hynes Reveal Secrets Behind Three Wisest Men

There’s a certain kind of holiday magic that only Hallmark manages to pull off. It’s that warm, cinnamon-scented blend of nostalgia, laughter, and heartfelt connection that just feels right this time of year.

This season, that magic’s dialed up as Paul Campbell and Tyler Hynes team up again for *Three Wisest Men*, the third chapter in the Brenner brothers saga. Even though Andrew Walker was missing from the press day, you could still feel the chemistry that’s become the heartbeat of the franchise.

Campbell and Hynes recently sat down to talk about their creative process, the bond that keeps them coming back, and what’s next for Hallmark’s favorite brotherhood. What came out? A mix of humor, humility, and pure holiday joy — that behind-the-scenes magic fans seem to crave.

The Brenner Brothers Are Back — And The Holiday Spirit Is Strong

Right from the start, it was obvious the *Three Wisest Men* press day wasn’t just business as usual. Campbell and Hynes brought the same energy that’s made their on-screen dynamic so loved.

Even with Walker absent, his presence was felt as the pair joked about needing their third brother to make things complete. That camaraderie, both real and fictional, is a big part of why this franchise stands out in Hallmark’s lineup.

Asked if they ever pictured the story stretching to a trilogy, Campbell was honest — it’s been a bit of a miracle. *We didn’t even know we’d get one movie,* he laughed, *and now we’re here talking about the third.*

Both actors are genuinely grateful to the fans who’ve made their brotherly antics a holiday tradition. Their excitement is less about the numbers, more about the joy of making something that brings people together.

From One to Three — The Evolution of a Hallmark Hit

Campbell says the jump from the first film to the third has been a surprise gift. Each installment lets them try something new emotionally, but the humor and heart always stick around.

Hynes agrees, calling the collaboration with Campbell and co-writer Kim a creative playground. *The fact that we’ve come this far is a gift,* he said, and you can tell their off-screen bond is just as real as what you see on TV.

Behind the laughter, there’s some serious dedication to making the story work. Campbell described how they approach each film like a puzzle, starting with a big emotional moment and then figuring out how to push the characters as far away from it as possible.

The result feels both fresh and familiar, with those Hallmark beats that somehow always hit you in the feels.

Why Fans Can’t Get Enough of the Wisest Men

It’s not just the holiday setting or the jokes that keep people tuning in. It’s the authenticity — that easy rhythm Hynes and Campbell have, which is really just a reflection of their real-life friendship.

Their chemistry is the secret sauce that turns these movies into something more than just seasonal fluff. Watching them, you’re not just seeing brothers on screen. You’re catching a real bond in motion.

Hynes summed it up: what drives them is creating a fulfilling experience for the audience. He’s always thinking about what’ll make fans actually feel something in the moment.

No wonder *Three Wisest Men* is buzzing as one of Hallmark’s most anticipated holiday releases.

The Secret Sauce: Humor, Heart, and a Little Holiday Chaos

There’s a kind of charm in how these movies balance comedy and emotion. Campbell said one of their rules is simple: if it makes them laugh, it probably deserves a spot in the script.

You can feel that playfulness in every scene. It gives the films a lived-in, spontaneous vibe that fans just eat up.

And then there’s Hynes’ character, Taylor — the smooth-talking, suit-wearing guy with a toothpick and a swagger that’s kind of become iconic. When asked how much of Taylor is actually Tyler, Hynes cracked, *Take away any intelligence or style, and you’ve got me.*

Campbell’s response? Just that brotherly silence — the kind that says plenty without needing to say anything at all.

Behind the Scenes: Building a Hallmark Classic

Campbell also let slip how much the team borrows from classic Christmas movies, sneaking in little nods for eagle-eyed fans. *It’s almost impossible not to borrow little pieces from the films that live in your subconscious,* he admitted.

That mix of reverence and originality is what makes *Three Wisest Men* feel both timeless and new.

Each film starts with a central theme or emotional core, then the writers work backward, challenging the characters as much as they can. It’s a storytelling trick that keeps the humor, heart, and growth all rolling together.

The result? A film that feels like a warm blanket on a snowy night — comforting, familiar, but still full of surprises.

Keeping the Band Together

There aren’t any official plans for a fourth movie right now, but Campbell and Hynes made it clear they’re not ready to call it quits. *The joy of these movies comes from working with this team,* Campbell said.

Whether it’s more *Wisest Men* or something totally new, they’re eager to keep collaborating. The band’s not breaking up just yet — and honestly, who wants them to?

That unity goes beyond just the actors. You can sense it in how the entire cast and crew approach each project, with real affection and respect for each other.

It’s that behind-the-scenes bond that somehow makes it onto the screen, and you can feel it every holiday season.

What the Wisest Men Want Fans to Know

As the chat wrapped up, the actors turned their focus to the fans. Campbell and Hynes both seemed genuinely moved by the support that’s carried the franchise through three films.

*We literally wouldn’t be here without them,* Campbell said, echoing that Hallmark spirit of community and connection.

Hynes kept it simple: *Thank you. Truly.* Sometimes that’s all that needs to be said.

Behind every cozy holiday movie is a team of storytellers who really do care about their audience. That sincerity is what keeps people coming back, year after year, ready to laugh, cry, and maybe believe in love all over again.

The Final Word: Holiday Joy, Hallmark Style

Before signing off, Hynes just had to squeeze in one last playful moment. He tossed out a mischievous bit of advice about taking photos with Campbell, and honestly, it captured their vibe perfectly.

Their conversation was brimming with humor and warmth, with a dash of chaos thrown in. Let’s face it—when it comes to the *Wisest Men*, “boring” just isn’t in their vocabulary.

With *Three Wisest Men*, Hallmark gives us more than just another holiday movie. It’s a celebration of friendship, creativity, and, yeah, a little gratitude too.

The best gifts? They’re wrapped in laughter, tied with heart, and sprinkled with a bit of Christmas mischief. Fans settling in with cocoa and twinkle lights can relax, knowing the Brenner brothers—and the actors behind them—are still out there spreading the kind of joy that makes the season actually shine.