Andrew Walker Names His Dream Hallmark Co-Stars

Hallmark heartthrob Andrew Walker has spent over a decade charming audiences with small-town romances, holiday magic, and those swoon-worthy meet-cutes. Even after becoming one of the network’s most dependable leading men, he’s still got big dreams about who he wants to fall in love with on screen next.

In a candid new interview, the fan-favorite actor revealed the two Hallmark stars at the very top of his wish list. Fans are already buzzing and campaigning for casting directors to make it happen.

Andrew Walker Reveals the Two Co-Stars He’s Manifesting Next

Walker’s built a career as one of Hallmark Channel’s most recognizable romantic leads. From breakout hits like Three Wise Men and a Baby to favorites like Bottled with Love, he’s become pretty much synonymous with the network’s blend of heartfelt stories and cozy charm.

Yet even with dozens of films under his belt, there are still a few pairings he hasn’t explored.

The Shortlist That Has Fans Buzzing

During a recent appearance on Crown Chats with host Haley, Walker got the question Hallmark fans have debated for years — who’s his dream co-star he hasn’t worked with yet? He didn’t hesitate, even if narrowing it down wasn’t easy.

The two names he landed on were:

• Kimberley Sustad
• Erin Cahill

Both actresses are fixtures in the Hallmark universe, each with passionate fan bases and long lists of holiday classics and romantic dramas. The twist? While Walker’s crossed paths with them professionally, he’s never headlined a romance opposite either one.

Why Kimberley Sustad Is a Perfect Match

Kimberley Sustad has carved out her own impressive legacy within Hallmark’s holiday canon. Known for her sparkling wit and natural chemistry with co-stars, Sustad first won over audiences in The Nine Lives of Christmas and later reprised her role in The Nine Kittens of Christmas.

She’s also shined in Christmas by Starlight, Wedding Every Weekend, and A Godwink Christmas. Interestingly, Sustad and Walker aren’t strangers.

They both appeared in A Bride for Christmas back in 2012, and she even made a cameo in Three Wise Men and a Baby. But they’ve never stood center stage together as the main love story. For longtime viewers, that feels like unfinished business, doesn’t it?

A Pairing That Feels Overdue

What makes this potential collaboration so compelling is the tonal match. Walker’s easygoing charm and grounded presence could blend seamlessly with Sustad’s sharp comedic timing and emotional depth.

Hallmark thrives on chemistry-driven storytelling, and this is one pairing that practically writes itself. Imagine a holiday film where opposites attract in a snow-covered town, or a summer romance where longtime rivals discover hidden sparks.

The possibilities? Pretty much endless. Fans are already tossing around ideas for scripts that could bring them together.

Erin Cahill’s Full-Circle Moment Waiting to Happen

If Walker’s mention of Sustad sparked excitement, his second choice added another layer of intrigue. Erin Cahill is another Hallmark staple, known for roles in Sleigh Bells Ring, Love, Fall and Order, A Timeless Christmas, The Secret Ingredient, and Christmas on Cherry Lane.

She’s also produced films like Every Time a Bell Rings, showing she’s invested in shaping Hallmark storytelling from more than one angle. The fascinating twist? Cahill has previously named Walker as one of the leading men she most wants to work with.

She’s known him for over a decade, yet they’ve never shared the screen in a Hallmark romance. That’s wild, right?

A Collaboration Fans Have Been Waiting For

There’s something undeniably appealing about two seasoned Hallmark pros finally joining forces. Both actors get the rhythm of the network’s romantic formula — the slow burn, the emotional confession, the inevitable grand gesture.

Pairing them could deliver a mature, layered love story that hits home with loyal viewers. Given Cahill’s producing experience, it’s not far-fetched to imagine her helping develop a project specifically tailored to their strengths.

If there was ever a Hallmark movie that felt destined to happen, this might be it.

Walker’s Titanic Comparison Raises Eyebrows

While Walker’s dreaming about future co-stars, he’s also gearing up for one of his most ambitious projects yet. During a recent television appearance, he compared his upcoming film Kentucky Roses to the epic scale of Titanic.

That’s not a comparison Hallmark fans hear every day. Walker explained that the story spans generations and centers around a missing heritage necklace that reconnects two unlikely people from very different worlds.

The film unfolds across two timelines — present day and 1932 — blending romance, family legacy, and long-buried secrets.

Inside Kentucky Roses

Set against the iconic backdrop of Churchill Downs, the story follows Sadie Moore, played by Odette Annable. Sadie works in the greenhouse and dreams of designing the Derby’s legendary garland of roses, honoring her great-grandmother’s legacy.

Walker plays Ash Taylor, the son of the Churchill Downs CEO, who arrives to repair storm damage just as Derby Day approaches. Their connection blossoms amid:

• Family expectations
• Generational secrets
• A mysterious necklace missing for a century
• The pressure of legacy versus forging a new path

With its dual timelines and sweeping themes, the film aims to elevate the traditional Hallmark romance into something more expansive and cinematic.

The Bigger Picture for Hallmark’s Leading Man

Walker’s continued success reflects Hallmark’s evolution. The network has leaned into deeper storytelling, layered characters, and multi-generational plots while keeping its comforting romantic core.

By openly naming dream collaborators, Walker’s signaling both gratitude for his past partnerships and excitement for fresh creative energy. After more than a decade in the Hallmark family, he’s not resting on familiarity.

He’s looking ahead — to new chemistry, new dynamics, and maybe even career-defining performances. Who knows what’s next?

Will Casting Directors Make It Happen?

In the world of Hallmark, fan enthusiasm can move mountains. Social media campaigns have nudged sequels, reunions, and even those endless holiday franchises into existence before.

Walker’s now openly cheering for Kimberley Sustad and Erin Cahill as his dream co-stars. At this point, the ball’s probably in the network’s court.

Audiences? Yeah, they’re ready. Whether it’s a snowy Christmas romance or a sun-soaked vineyard story, folks are waiting to see Andrew Walker finally team up with one of his top picks.