Benjamin Ayres Joins Hallmark’s Mistletoe Murders Season 2

Hallmark is really turning up the holiday heat this year, and fans can barely keep their excitement in check. The network’s mystery series Mistletoe Murders is coming back for its second season on November 7, 2025.

The first two episodes will even feature a surprise cameo that’s bound to thrill devoted viewers. Hallmark favorite Benjamin Ayres is joining stars Sarah Drew and Peter Mooney for a festive, suspense-filled adventure—mixing cozy Christmas vibes with a bit of danger.

Ayres, who’s made a name for himself in Hallmark hits and series like Saving Hope and Suits, recently shared some behind-the-scenes stories about filming the show. His excitement is honestly kind of infectious.

From Toronto filming shenanigans to his genuine admiration for his co-stars, Ayres’ involvement just adds an extra spark to the already beloved series. Here’s a look at why his return to the Hallmark universe is getting people talking—and why this season of Mistletoe Murders might be the most thrilling holiday treat yet.

The Magic of Hallmark’s Holiday Mysteries Returns

Hallmark is pretty much the go-to for heartwarming holiday stories, but their dive into mystery has definitely spiced things up. Mistletoe Murders first got audiences hooked with its blend of small-town charm, suspense, and that unmistakable festive spirit.

Now, with season two on the way, fans are ready for more—and maybe a few curveballs. The show follows Emily and Sam, played by Sarah Drew and Peter Mooney, as they unravel crimes surrounded by twinkling lights and, of course, mistletoe.

This season, Emily and Sam are back together to solve the puzzling disappearance of a school chess coach. The case stirs up echoes of Emily’s past and puts their partnership to the test in ways they haven’t faced before.

Bringing Benjamin Ayres into the mix only ramps up the anticipation. The guy’s got a knack for layered, interesting characters, which fits perfectly with a show that thrives on both mystery and emotion.

Fans who’ve followed his career know Ayres brings both depth and charisma—this cameo shouldn’t be any different.

Benjamin Ayres: From Leading Man to Scene-Stealing Cameo

Benjamin Ayres has built a reputation as one of Hallmark’s most reliable leading men, but he’s not shy about changing things up. In a chat with EntertainmentNow, Ayres talked about how much fun it is to jump into different roles, especially when it means breaking away from his usual romantic hero vibe.

He called it an *honor* to be part of Mistletoe Murders, saying it was a refreshing change of pace. Filming in Toronto—his hometown—made it even more special, letting him reconnect with familiar faces both on and off set.

Ayres dropped a hint that his character might get *embroiled in something he shouldn’t be doing*, suggesting a storyline that’s not so black-and-white. He also said viewers might end up sympathizing with his character, even as the mystery gets deeper.

That kind of moral complexity is what’s been setting Hallmark’s newer mysteries apart. It’s not just cozy cheer—they actually keep you guessing.

Behind the Scenes: Friendship, Fun, and Festive Filming

One of the best parts of Ayres’ involvement is the real friendship he shares with his co-stars. He’s known Sarah Drew for years and has worked with Peter Mooney before, on both Saving Hope and Rookie Blue.

That off-screen camaraderie shows up on screen, giving the series the kind of easy chemistry Hallmark fans love. Ayres even remembered how excited he was when Drew first landed the series, and talked about a pre-season sushi dinner where she couldn’t stop raving about the script.

This project clearly means a lot to everyone involved. That shared enthusiasm? It’s bound to come through in every scene.

Toronto: The Perfect Holiday Backdrop

Filming in Toronto felt like a homecoming for Ayres. The city’s snow-dusted streets and cozy little cafes make for the perfect setting—urban, but still with that small-town charm.

Ayres mentioned how much he loved being back in familiar surroundings, working with a cast and crew that felt almost like family. That sense of comfort and connection is honestly part of what makes Hallmark movies so special—they make you feel at home, whether you’re on set or just watching from the couch.

For longtime fans, seeing Ayres back in a Hallmark project—even in a cameo—feels like welcoming an old friend for the holidays. There’s a nostalgic warmth to it, but his mysterious storyline also brings a fresh twist.

What to Expect from Season Two of Mistletoe Murders

According to Hallmark’s official logline, season two kicks off with Emily and Sam reuniting to investigate the disappearance of a school chess coach. Of course, in true mystery fashion, the case is more complicated than it seems.

The investigation reopens old wounds for Emily, pushing her to face parts of her past she thought she’d left behind. With Ayres’ character tangled in the intrigue, viewers can expect both emotional stakes and plenty of suspense.

The holiday setting just makes everything pop—every snowflake and carol could be a clue. For fans who want more than just mistletoe kisses, this series hits the sweet spot between romance, suspense, and seasonal spirit.

Ayres’ Hallmark Legacy

Benjamin Ayres has a long history with Hallmark. He’s starred in loads of fan-favorites, including his latest, A Christmas Angel Match with Meghan Ory.

There’s a sincerity and warmth he brings to every role, and that’s made him a staple on the network. But what really sets him apart? He’s willing to take risks and try roles that push him as an actor.

In Mistletoe Murders, Ayres gets to do exactly that. By playing a character who isn’t exactly your typical “good guy,” he brings in some extra nuance and unpredictability.

It’s a move that keeps things interesting for viewers and shows Hallmark’s commitment to more layered storytelling.

Why Fans Can’t Miss This Holiday Premiere

With the premiere set for November 7, 2025, at 8 p.m. Eastern on the Hallmark Channel, Mistletoe Murders season two is shaping up to be a must-watch for the holidays. The first season’s already streaming on Hallmark+, so there’s time to catch up before new episodes drop.

Between the returning stars, a brand-new mystery, and Benjamin Ayres’ much-anticipated cameo, there are plenty of reasons to tune in.

• Star Power: Sarah Drew, Peter Mooney, and Benjamin Ayres have genuine chemistry that lights up the screen.
• Holiday Mystery: It’s the perfect mix of festive vibes and suspenseful twists.
• Emotional Depth: Themes of redemption, friendship, and second chances add real heart to the intrigue.
• Visual Magic: Toronto’s winter streets give the series a cinematic, holiday glow.

The Final Word

After decades in the entertainment industry, Hallmark’s figured out how to deliver what audiences really crave — warmth, wonder, and just enough mystery to keep you guessing. Mistletoe Murders leans right into all of that.

Benjamin Ayres joins the cast, and honestly, fans can probably expect him to bring a performance that’s both heartfelt and a little bit haunting. It feels like a perfect fit for a season that’s all about love, forgiveness, and maybe even some fresh starts.

Whether you’re a Hallmark regular or just a little curious because you heard it’s a clever whodunit, this holiday premiere is tough to pass up. Why not grab your cocoa, light a fire, and see what secrets Mistletoe Murders is hiding?

When Hallmark tosses mystery into the holiday mix, you never quite know what you’ll get — but it’s usually some kind of magic.