Curious Caterer Update: Andrew Walker Reveals Hallmark Future

Hallmark fans hoping for a long-awaited return to one of the network’s most beloved mystery franchises might want to brace themselves. Despite earlier optimism and even some pretty confident hints that more films were coming, the future of Curious Caterer is suddenly up in the air.

Andrew Walker, who stars alongside Nikki DeLoach in the series, has offered a surprising new take on whether Goldy Berry and Detective Tom Schultz will be back to solve more crimes. And, of course, continue their slow-burn romance.

A Promising Future Suddenly Feels Uncertain

For months, Hallmark mystery lovers have clung to hopeful comments that new Curious Caterer movies weren’t just possible, but practically a sure thing. The fifth movie premiered in October 2024, and the ending left the door wide open for more — both in terms of story and romance.

But here we are, more than a year and a half later, and there’s still no real word on production dates. No official announcements, no green light from the network, nothing solid to go on.

Andrew Walker’s Tone Has Changed

In a recent interview, Walker admitted there are currently no definite plans to bring the franchise back. That’s a noticeable shift from his earlier, much more upbeat attitude.

He used to say, with real conviction, that more movies were in the works. He’d even mentioned that trusted sources told him new installments were coming the following year.

Now, he’s encouraging viewers to reach out to Hallmark and make some noise if they want to see Goldy and Tom return. So, it sounds like fan demand could really tip the scales here.

Translation? The door isn’t closed, but it’s definitely not wide open either.

Why Curious Caterer Became a Hallmark Favorite

When Curious Caterer: Dying for Chocolate debuted in 2022, it quickly found its own little niche in Hallmark’s mystery lineup. The idea was just too good: a talented caterer who keeps stumbling onto murder investigations, teaming up with a charming detective to solve crimes in their small town.

Across five films, Goldy Berry went from accidental sleuth to trusted investigative partner. Detective Tom Schultz, meanwhile, gradually let his guard down and built a real connection with Goldy — both professionally and personally.

The Romance That Hooked Viewers

By the time the fifth movie, Forbidden Fruit, aired in October 2024, Goldy and Tom’s chemistry hit a new level. After years of lingering glances and witty banter, the two finally shared their first kiss.

For fans, that moment felt huge — like the start of something new.

• Would they finally become a couple?
• How would their romance shake up their crime-solving?
• Could wedding bells be next?

Scripts for future movies have reportedly already been written. Walker has even hinted that upcoming stories would dig deeper into both the supporting cast and the central romance.

There Are Stories Left to Tell

One of the most interesting possibilities, if the series continues, is a bigger spotlight on the ensemble. Walker’s mentioned that future films would explore the lives and backstories of the folks orbiting Goldy and Tom.

That means more of Goldy’s loyal best friend Marla Maguire and Tom’s reliable deputy Mason. They haven’t been in the spotlight, but honestly, they’ve become fan favorites in their own right.

Expanding the Cozy Mystery Universe

The best part of a long-running mystery series is watching the characters grow, even as the cases keep coming. Each new mystery brings fresh suspects and twists, but it’s the familiar faces that keep people tuning in.

Walker has pointed out that there are plenty of fun ways to explore hobbies, relationships, and hidden sides of the ensemble. In this genre, community really is everything — and that kind of storytelling can make a series feel essential, not just entertaining.

And with scripts apparently ready to go, the creative groundwork is there.

Andrew Walker Is Ready — Right Now

If scheduling were the problem, fans might have more reason to worry. Hallmark stars are often juggling a bunch of projects at once, especially folks like Walker and DeLoach.

But here’s the twist: Walker says his schedule is wide open. After his latest Hallmark film, Kentucky Roses, he’s made it clear he’d happily jump right back into filming Curious Caterer.

So, the star isn’t what’s holding things up.

So What Is Holding It Up?

Hallmark’s programming strategy might be part of the puzzle. The network used to have a packed lineup of cozy mysteries, but lately, there have been some shifts in what gets priority.

Still, mystery fans aren’t being totally ignored this May. The network is rolling out three returning franchises:

• May 16: Alison Sweeney and Victor Webster in Hannah Swensen Mysteries: Best Served Cold
• May 23: Nikki DeLoach in the second True Justice movie, Eye for an Eye
• May 30: Tamera Mowry-Housely in Haunted Harmony Mysteries: Key to the Castle

The appetite for cozy crime-solving is clearly still there. The only real question: will Curious Caterer get back in the mix?

Can Fan Power Bring Goldy and Tom Back?

TV history is full of shows that got a second life thanks to passionate fans. From canceled dramas that came back years later to fan campaigns that saved beloved series, audience enthusiasm can move the needle — or at least get the network’s attention.

Walker’s suggestion to message Hallmark and show support seems pretty intentional. It’s a sign the cast is on board, but the future of the series might just depend on how much noise the fans make.

The Stakes Feel Higher After That Kiss

Ending a film series right after a romantic breakthrough? That’s almost cruel. Goldy and Tom’s first kiss finally happened, and it set up so much more story to tell.

Walking away now would just leave things hanging. For a franchise built on slow-burn romance and small-town charm, closure actually matters.

Fans have watched these two dance around each other for four years. They want to know what comes next—don’t we all?

For now, Curious Caterer is stuck in limbo. Not canceled, not renewed, just sort of…waiting.

Apparently, the scripts are already written. The lead actor’s around, ready to go. Fans are making noise online. All the pieces are there, just waiting to be used.

Will Hallmark listen? That’s the real mystery, isn’t it?

Whether Hallmark dishes out another Goldy Berry mystery might just depend on how much viewers want it. Sometimes, you have to ask for seconds.