Elizabeth Henstridge Drops Behind-the-Scenes Gold for ‘Mystery Island: Play For Keeps’ – Don’t Miss the Adorable Sloth!
Elizabeth Henstridge is back with another thrilling installment in Hallmark’s Mystery Island series! The third film, Mystery Island: Play For Keeps, drops tonight at 9:00pm ET.
Henstridge, known for her charisma and knack for making every scene pop, just shared a behind-the-scenes slideshow on Instagram. Fans get a peek at playful on-set moments, plus some candid shots of the cast and crew just goofing around or deep in the filmmaking grind.
Find the best accommodations and airfares
Check availability at 5* hotels, guest houses and apartments rated "superb" or "exceptional" by visitors just like you.
NO RESERVATION FEES
CHECK AVAILABILITY FOR YOUR DATES HERE
There’s a real sense of excitement in her post. You can almost feel the fun they had, whether it’s a quick smile in the makeup chair or the cast joking around between takes.
One photo that stands out? Henstridge, mid-prep, grinning in the makeup chair. Then there’s a snap of the crew hustling on that gorgeous island location—honestly, it almost looks like a vacation, except for all the equipment and, well, the work.
And, because it’s Hallmark, there’s an adorable video of a sloth thrown in. Who doesn’t love a little animal cameo?
Table of Contents
Elizabeth Henstridge’s Behind-the-Scenes Tease
Elizabeth’s Instagram update has fans buzzing. The slideshow really captures the energy on set for Mystery Island: Play For Keeps.
Her personality just jumps out of every shot. It’s obvious the whole team was having a blast bringing this movie together.
There’s a shot of her in the makeup chair, looking ready for anything. Another pic shows everyone hard at work, surrounded by palm trees and blue skies.
And, seriously, the sloth video? It just adds that perfect, quirky Hallmark touch.
Island Life and Bug Spray
Island life looks dreamy, but Henstridge makes sure to keep it real. She posted a photo of a mountain of bug spray—turns out, paradise comes with mosquitoes.
Honestly, it’s a refreshing reminder that even movie magic has its messy bits. These little glimpses make the cast and crew feel more relatable, like they’re just a bunch of people trying not to get bitten alive while filming your new favorite movie.
The Journey of Mystery Island
The Mystery Island series first aired in September 2023. It quickly hooked viewers with twisty plots, clever clues, and a fun mix of suspense and lightheartedness.
With each new movie, the fanbase has just grown. Mystery Island: Winner Takes All (March 2025) kept the momentum going, proving the franchise has real staying power with Hallmark audiences.
Henstridge-Weber Dynamic
One thing fans keep coming back for? The chemistry between Elizabeth Henstridge and Charlie Weber. Their on-screen dynamic is a big reason the series works so well.
The way their characters bounce off each other brings both charm and suspense. With both leads returning for Play For Keeps, you can bet there’ll be more of that same spark that’s made the series a fan favorite.
What to Expect in Play For Keeps
So what’s in store for Mystery Island: Play For Keeps? Expect another round of twisty mysteries and clever clues.
Henstridge and Weber are front and center again, so there’s bound to be suspense and a few surprises. Judging by the behind-the-scenes shots, the whole crew had a genuinely good time making this one.
Premiere Details
Set a reminder—Mystery Island: Play For Keeps airs tonight, Sunday, August 17, 2025, at 9:00pm ET on Hallmark. If you’ve been following the series, you probably already have plans.
If you’re new to the Mystery Island world, honestly, now’s a great time to jump in. The earlier films are streaming on Hallmark+, so you can catch up on all the twists and shenanigans from the start.
Looking Ahead: House Rules
The ride doesn’t stop with Play For Keeps. The next chapter, Mystery Island: House Rules, is set for Sunday, September 14, 2025.
Hallmark’s keeping the details close to the vest for now. But with the way things are going, there’s no sign of the series slowing down.
The Future of Mystery Island
Fans are already speculating about what’s next for Mystery Island. No official word yet about more movies, but honestly, with this much love for the series, it wouldn’t be a shock if there are more mysteries coming.
For now, just enjoy Play For Keeps and get ready for another round in September. It’s shaping up to be a fun season for mystery lovers.
Why You Should Tune In
If you’re into suspense, a bit of charm, and a good old-fashioned whodunit, Mystery Island: Play For Keeps is worth a watch. The series really hits that sweet spot for Hallmark fans who want a little heart with their mysteries.
With Henstridge and Weber leading the way, you’re in for a genuinely entertaining ride. It’s got all the right ingredients—mystery, chemistry, and just enough unpredictability to keep you guessing.
Final Thoughts
Elizabeth Henstridge’s playful behind-the-scenes tease has definitely cranked up the anticipation for *Mystery Island: Play For Keeps*.
Fans are gearing up for another round, and honestly, the *Mystery Island* series just keeps pulling people in with its mix of suspense and clever clues.
Don’t forget—the premiere’s tonight at 9:00pm ET on Hallmark.
Might as well get comfy and see what wild twists this latest adventure has in store!
Christmas Market Closures
Due to econonic conditions and tariffs, some Christmas Markets may cancel their events due to lack of vendors. If you are aware of a closed market,or find errors on a listing or an image, please reach out on our Contact Us page so that we may update this post.