Hallmark Renews Mistletoe Murders for Season Three

Hallmark just dropped an early Christmas treat for mystery fans. The cozy crime drama Mistletoe Murders is coming back for a third season, so if you’re into festive whodunits, you can start counting down the days until Fletcher’s Grove lights up again.

Romance, secrets, and a jaw-dropping cliffhanger wrapped up season two. Somehow, this holiday mystery has quietly become one of Hallmark’s most talked-about originals.

Production’s kicking off later this year. The new season will premiere during Hallmark’s beloved Countdown to Christmas event, and honestly, it sounds like it’s going to be the most intense chapter yet.

Hallmark’s Holiday Mystery Hit Returns

Standing out in Hallmark’s sea of feel-good romances and festive comfort movies isn’t easy. But Mistletoe Murders has found its own little corner by mixing small-town coziness with real suspense.

The story follows Emily Lane, played by Sarah Drew. She runs a year-round Christmas shop, all smiles on the outside, but she’s hiding a past she’d rather forget.

The show’s renewal isn’t just another season—it’s proof that audiences are hooked on this combo of romance, community, and murder mystery. Network execs say the first two seasons got a huge response, so it’s no surprise this one’s now a fan favorite in Hallmark’s growing mystery lineup.

Why Season Three Is a Big Deal

Season two didn’t tiptoe out. It left us with a cliffhanger that really turned up the heat for Emily and Detective Sam Wilner, played by Peter Mooney.

Their partnership—both on the job and off—has been the heart of the series. But with Sam getting closer to the truth about Emily’s shadowy past, things are more tense than ever.

Season three is set to dig into:

• Emily’s secret history and whatever fallout is finally coming her way
• Her complicated relationship with Sam, who’s starting to realize the biggest mystery may not be the murders after all
• Brand new crimes in Fletcher’s Grove threatening the town’s cozy image
• Unfinished business from last season’s wild ending

The Cast That Keeps Fans Coming Back

The cast is a big part of why people keep tuning in. Sarah Drew—maybe you remember her from Grey’s Anatomy—not only stars as Emily but also steps in as an executive producer.

She brings a mix of warmth and quiet intensity to Emily, making her one of Hallmark’s most interesting leads. Peter Mooney gives Detective Sam Wilner both sharpness and sincerity, and their chemistry has fans guessing what’s next for them.

The supporting cast brings even more life to Fletcher’s Grove:

• Sierra Marilyn Riley
• Jean Yoon
• Lara Amersey
• Kylee Evans

Each character adds to that layered, close-knit community vibe. And honestly, the town itself feels like a character—festive, charming, and hiding more secrets than you’d think.

A Creative Team With a Clear Vision

Behind the scenes, showrunner and executive producer Ken Cuperus leads the way. He clearly loves blending Christmas coziness with a good murder mystery.

Lionsgate Canada and Headspinner Productions team up on production, with Lionsgate Television handling international distribution. That partnership keeps the show looking sharp and lets it lean into its unique tone—cozy but never corny, romantic but not predictable.

From Audible Hit to Streaming Success

Some fans might not know Mistletoe Murders actually started as an Audible Original series. The audio drama featured Cobie Smulders, Raymond Ablack, and Anna Cathcart, and ran for four seasons, gathering a loyal following.

That built-in fanbase helped the TV version hit the ground running. Moving from audio to screen opened up the story visually, but the heart of it—those character moments—stayed front and center.

If you found the series on Audible, chances are you’ve already jumped into the Hallmark version. If not, you can catch up with seasons one and two on Hallmark+ before season three drops for the holidays.

Countdown to Christmas Just Got More Exciting

Hallmark’s Countdown to Christmas is a holiday ritual for millions. It’s packed with romantic premieres and nostalgic favorites, basically taking over December TV schedules.

Adding a new season of Mistletoe Murders gives the lineup a little edge for viewers who want something besides the usual love stories. By putting the premiere in this prime slot, Hallmark’s showing real confidence—it’s not just background noise, it’s a main attraction.

What Fans Can Expect Next

There’s no official premiere date yet. Production kicks off later this year.

That timing suggests a late-year debut. Honestly, it feels like they’re aiming to catch viewers during the holiday rush.

Expect:

• More layered storytelling that digs into Emily’s past
• Extra romantic tension between Emily and Sam
• A new central mystery woven through the ongoing character arcs
• That unmistakable holiday vibe that makes the show stand out

The TV world’s packed with crime shows and cookie-cutter holiday romances. Mistletoe Murders somehow sits right in the middle.

It’s got comfort, but there’s still suspense. Romance, but the plot keeps moving.

With season three on the horizon, Fletcher’s Grove is just about ready to pull us back in. Secrets, sleigh bells, maybe a little danger—sounds like Christmas here is never boring.