Hallmark Stars Kevin McGarry and Eloise Mumford Tease Villa Amore Sequel

Hallmark fans are buzzing with excitement as speculation grows around a possible sequel to Villa Amore, the Italy-set romantic comedy that charmed audiences this past June.

Starring Kevin McGarry and Eloise Mumford, the film followed Leo and Liara as they renovated a picturesque villa where her parents once fell in love.

Their on-screen chemistry, the breathtaking Italian backdrop, and the heartfelt storyline made the movie an instant favorite.

Now, thanks to playful social media exchanges between the stars, whispers of a sequel are getting louder.

Fans are left wondering if Hallmark will send us back to Italy for another round of romance, laughter, and maybe even more villa renovations.

The Social Media Tease That Sparked the Buzz

It all started when Eloise Mumford shared an Instagram Story in late September featuring a stunning house for sale in Italy.

She tagged Kevin McGarry with a cheeky suggestion that they should take on another project together.

McGarry quickly joined in on the fun, reposting her story with playful hints at a sequel and even adding the hashtag #villaamore.

Fans immediately began speculating that this wasn’t just a casual exchange but perhaps a subtle nod to what could come next.

Why Fans Are Taking This Seriously

While actors often joke around online, this particular exchange feels different.

Mumford has already gone on record saying she’d love a part two, even posting earlier this year that the story and characters deserve more time on screen.

McGarry has also praised working with Mumford, calling her immensely talented and highlighting the unique charm of their characters’ romance.

With both stars openly enthusiastic, it’s hard not to think Hallmark might take notice.

The Magic of Italy and Why It Worked

One of the biggest draws of Villa Amore was its setting.

Italy’s rolling hills, rustic villas, and romantic atmosphere created the perfect backdrop for a love story.

Viewers weren’t just watching Leo and Liara fall for each other — they were also falling in love with the country itself.

The film blended travel escapism with heartfelt storytelling, making it more than just another Hallmark romance.

It became an experience, a cinematic getaway that fans now want to revisit.

How a Sequel Could Expand the Story

If Hallmark greenlights a sequel, the possibilities are endless.

Imagine Leo and Liara tackling another dilapidated villa, maybe with even bigger challenges and higher stakes.

Would they consider turning their passion for renovations into a business?

Could friends or family join them in Italy, adding new dynamics and comedic moments?

A second film could also deepen their relationship, showing how their romance evolves beyond the initial spark.

• More stunning Italian villas waiting to be restored
• New characters who could bring both conflict and comedy
• Deeper exploration of Leo and Liara’s relationship
• Opportunities for Hallmark to create a franchise around travel and romance

Kevin McGarry’s Busy Schedule

One factor fans are watching closely is Kevin McGarry’s availability.

The actor is currently filming season 13 of When Calls the Heart, which is slated to premiere in 2026.

However, with production timelines and breaks built into his schedule, there’s a window for him to take on another project.

This makes the possibility of a Villa Amore sequel even more realistic, especially if Hallmark sees the demand.

Why Hallmark Might Say Yes

Hallmark has a history of capitalizing on fan-favorite movies by creating sequels or even trilogies.

Titles like The Wedding Veil series have proven that viewers love following beloved characters across multiple films.

With Villa Amore already being praised as a standout, Hallmark has every reason to consider giving audiences more.

The combination of romance, travel, and home renovation is a winning formula that could easily become a recurring theme.

The Fan Response So Far

Since the social media posts went live, fans have been flooding comment sections with excitement.

Many are sharing their dream scenarios for a sequel, from wedding bells in Italy to an expanded storyline that introduces new love interests for supporting characters.

The enthusiasm is palpable, and in today’s entertainment landscape, fan demand often plays a huge role in what gets greenlit.

What Makes This Sequel Different

Unlike some sequels that feel forced, a second Villa Amore movie has organic momentum.

The characters’ journey doesn’t feel complete, and the setting practically begs for another story.

The real-life chemistry between McGarry and Mumford makes their dynamic irresistible.

When both the cast and the fans are pushing for more, it’s a recipe for success.

Imagining the Next Chapter

So what could a sequel actually look like? Here are a few possibilities:

• A wedding in Italy where Leo and Liara tie the knot in a historic villa
• A new business venture where they buy and restore properties for others
• Family drama as relatives come to visit and bring complications
• Unexpected twists like financial struggles, rival renovators, or even a hidden family secret tied to a villa

Potential for a Franchise

If done right, Villa Amore could become more than just a one-off sequel.

Hallmark could expand it into a series of films, each set in a different Italian town with new villas to restore.

This would allow the network to give fans a mix of continuity with Leo and Liara while also introducing fresh stories and characters.

It could be the start of a new travel-romance brand for Hallmark.

What’s Next for Hallmark

As of now, Hallmark hasn’t officially announced a sequel.

But with the stars openly teasing the idea, the timing feels perfect.

The network is always looking for ways to keep its lineup fresh, and a return to Italy could be just the thing to capture viewers’ attention.

Whether it’s a direct sequel or the start of a larger series, the potential is undeniable.

Why Fans Should Stay Hopeful

Even without an official confirmation, the signs are encouraging.

Mumford and McGarry are both enthusiastic, the fanbase is vocal, and Hallmark has a proven track record of listening to its audience.

If the buzz continues to grow, it may only be a matter of time before the network makes an announcement.

Until then, fans can keep dreaming about cobblestone streets, rustic villas, and the next chapter of Leo and Liara’s love story.

Final Thoughts

Villa Amore really managed to charm everyone with its mix of romance, humor, and that unmistakable Italian vibe.

Now, with both stars dropping hints and fans begging for more, the idea of a sequel feels less like wishful thinking and more like a matter of time.

Maybe Leo and Liara will fix up another villa, plan a wedding, or just get swept up in something totally unexpected.

Either way, people are itching to head back to Italy with them. For Hallmark, it’s honestly a can’t-miss opportunity.