Lacey Chabert and Andrew Walker Reunite for New Hallmark Holiday Film

Hallmark fans, get ready to unwrap a brand-new holiday treat this season! Lacey Chabert and Andrew Walker — two of the network’s most beloved stars — are reuniting after seven years for a festive film that promises laughter, heart, and that signature Hallmark warmth.

Their upcoming movie, She’s Making a List, premieres December 6 and is already creating buzz for being a refreshing twist on the classic holiday romance formula. With Chabert portraying a Naughty or Nice list inspector and Walker stepping into the role of a widowed father, this film offers more than just mistletoe moments.

It’s a story about empathy, second chances, and rediscovering what truly matters during the holidays. I mean, who can resist that?

The Dynamic Duo Returns to Hallmark Magic

It’s been seven years since Lacey Chabert and Andrew Walker last shared the screen in My Secret Valentine, a romantic comedy about mysterious chalkboard messages and unexpected love. Now, the pair is back with She’s Making a List, and Chabert insists this new film is very different from their previous collaboration.

While My Secret Valentine was rooted in secret notes and family winery drama, She’s Making a List takes a more whimsical and heartfelt approach. It blends humor, fantasy, and emotional depth in a way that feels refreshingly new for Hallmark’s holiday lineup.

Chabert, who’s basically the unofficial Queen of Hallmark Christmas movies at this point, describes this project as both funny and poignant. She says the film will leave audiences feeling uplifted and filled with goodness, which honestly, sounds like something we could all use right now.

For longtime fans of the duo, this reunion feels like a gift wrapped in tinsel and tied with nostalgia. Their on-screen chemistry just keeps shining, year after year.

A Storyline That Mixes Holiday Magic With Heart

In She’s Making a List, Chabert plays Isabel, a dedicated Naughty or Nice list inspector who’s tasked with evaluating the behavior of an 11-year-old named Charlie, played by Cadence Compton. What seems like a routine case quickly turns into something far more personal when Isabel meets Charlie’s widowed father, Jason, portrayed by Walker.

As Isabel spends more time with the father-daughter duo, she begins to question not only her job but also the very rules that guide her life. The movie uses this clever premise to explore themes of compassion, understanding, and the gray areas that exist between naughty and nice.

What makes this film stand out is how it balances humor with heartfelt emotion. Chabert reveals that Isabel’s journey involves a series of disguises and undercover attempts that often go hilariously wrong.

Beneath the comedy, though, is a story about connection — the kind that bridges generations and heals old wounds. The character of Charlie becomes a mirror for Isabel, helping her rediscover empathy and a deeper understanding of the world around her.

Why This Reunion Feels So Special

Fans have long adored the natural chemistry between Lacey Chabert and Andrew Walker, and it’s no surprise that their off-screen friendship translates beautifully on camera. Chabert has described Walker as the kindest human and a great costar who can ad-lib and roll with any scene.

That kind of creative synergy is rare, and it’s part of what makes their collaborations feel so authentic. The two share a shorthand that only comes from years of genuine friendship — their families even know each other outside of work.

Filming took place in Vancouver over three weeks. Chabert says the experience was a blast from start to finish.

The comfort level between the actors allowed them to play, improvise, and bring extra layers of emotion to their scenes. For viewers, that means more organic banter, believable chemistry, and a story that feels lived-in rather than scripted.

If you’ve ever wished you could step into a Hallmark movie, this one might be the closest you’ll get. Maybe it’s not magic, but it’s close.

Beyond Romance: A Deeper Message

While Hallmark movies are famous for their swoon-worthy love stories, She’s Making a List aims to go beyond the typical romantic arc. Chabert emphasizes that the film isn’t just about Isabel and Jason’s growing connection — it’s also about the bond that forms between Isabel and Charlie.

Through their interactions, Isabel begins to see the world differently, recognizing that everyone has their own struggles and triumphs that can’t simply be categorized as good or bad. There’s a realness to that, isn’t there?

The Hallmark Touch: Comfort, Joy, and Holiday Spirit

There’s something undeniably comforting about a Hallmark Christmas movie. The snow-covered streets, the twinkling lights, the cozy small-town charm — it’s cinematic hot cocoa for the soul.

She’s Making a List captures all of that and more. From Isabel’s whimsical disguises to the heartfelt family moments, the film promises to deliver everything fans love about Hallmark’s holiday tradition while adding a few delightful surprises along the way.

Chabert’s portrayal of Isabel is both comedic and touching. Walker’s Jason brings warmth and sincerity to the role of a devoted father.

Together, they embody the spirit of Christmas — imperfect, hopeful, and full of heart. The movie’s balance of humor and emotion ensures that it will appeal to both longtime Hallmark devotees and newcomers looking for a feel-good escape.

Lacey Chabert’s Holiday Empire Grows

As if starring in another Hallmark hit weren’t enough, Chabert is also celebrating the launch of her very own Hallmark holiday collection. The line features festive paper products, serving trays, and kitchen items — all designed to bring a touch of Hallmark magic into fans’ homes.

For Chabert, who admits she loves Christmas decor, this collaboration is a dream come true. She’s proud to create something that lets her be part of other people’s celebrations, and it’s easy to see why fans are already eager to shop the collection.

• Festive paper goods perfect for holiday entertaining
• Charming serving trays for Christmas parties and gatherings
• Holiday kitchen items that blend function with seasonal flair

By expanding her partnership with Hallmark beyond film, Chabert continues to cement her place as one of the network’s most beloved and influential stars. Her passion for Christmas — both on-screen and off — shines through everything she does.

When and Where to Watch

She’s Making a List premieres on Hallmark Channel, Saturday, December 6, at 8 p.m. ET. Whether you’re tuning in for the romance, the laughs, or just to bask in that Hallmark glow, this movie promises to deliver all the cozy feels of the season.

Pair it with a cup of cocoa, a fuzzy blanket, and maybe even a few of Chabert’s new holiday products for the ultimate viewing experience. I know I’ll be watching — will you?

Final Thoughts: A Must-Watch Holiday Gem

After thirty years of writing about entertainment, I’ve seen my share of holiday movies come and go. Still, *She’s Making a List* feels different—like it’s quietly waiting to surprise everyone this season.

It’s got that perfect mix: a sweet story, a little bit of magic, and leads with real spark. Honestly, Lacey Chabert and Andrew Walker together again? That alone is almost enough to tune in, even if you’re not a Hallmark diehard.

There’s something comforting about movies like this. They remind us why the holidays matter—connection, forgiveness, and finding joy in places we didn’t expect.

So maybe set a reminder. Or don’t, and just catch it when you need a little warmth. Either way, *She’s Making a List* brings the kind of kindness and magic that Hallmark does best, even if you’ve seen it all before.