Sarah Drew Leads Mistletoe Murders Season 2 With Heart

It’s officially mystery season again on Hallmark Channel. That means one thing—Sarah Drew is back to sleuth her way through more festive intrigue in *Mistletoe Murders* Season 2.

The actress, beloved for her warm charm and emotional depth, returns as Emily Lane. Emily’s secrets have captivated audiences since the show’s debut.

This time, Drew isn’t just front and center on screen; she’s also flexing her creative muscles behind the camera as a producer. She’s continuing her evolution from actor to multi-hyphenate powerhouse.

In a recent chat with TVBrittanyF.com, Drew opened up about her creative journey and her dynamic chemistry with co-star Peter Mooney. She hinted that fans can expect *a lot of heart*—and even more mystery—in the new season.

Sarah Drew’s Creative Evolution: From Actress to Storyteller

Before she was solving crimes under the mistletoe, Sarah Drew was already crafting stories in her own right. Her passion for writing and directing began long before Hollywood came calling.

In high school and college, Drew was constantly creating—writing plays, directing small productions, and leading community groups. That early spark of leadership has clearly never left her.

When she began producing on the faith-based drama *Indivisible*, she realized she wanted a seat at the creative table. Not just in front of the camera but behind it as well.

That decision opened doors to new opportunities. Producing *Indivisible* gave her the confidence to direct, which led to her directing a *Grey’s Anatomy* web series that even earned Emmy recognition.

From there, she dove into writing, pitching a Christmas movie idea that quickly became a full-fledged script. The producers encouraged her to take the reins, and she wrote her first draft in just three weeks.

That experience, she said, *lit a fire* that continues to shape her career today. It’s clear she hasn’t looked back.

Balancing Acting and Producing on *Mistletoe Murders*

As both star and producer of *Mistletoe Murders*, Drew brings a holistic approach to storytelling. She’s deeply involved in every layer of production—from script notes to blocking scenes on set.

Her attention to detail is meticulous. *I care about props, blocking, and continuity,* she shared, emphasizing that her producer’s mindset never fully switches off, even when she’s in character.

Yet once the cameras roll, she’s fully immersed in Emily Lane’s world. She navigates the emotional beats of each scene with precision.

This dual perspective gives Drew a rare creative synergy. She’s not just performing the story—she’s shaping it.

That collaboration extends to her fellow cast and crew. She values open communication and logical storytelling.

For Drew, it’s not about control; it’s about connection. Every choice, from how a scene is staged to how a line is delivered, serves the greater narrative.

The Chemistry That Keeps Fans Hooked

No Hallmark mystery would be complete without a touch of romance, and *Mistletoe Murders* delivers that in spades. The electric tension between Emily Lane and Detective Sam Wilner, played by Peter Mooney, is one of the show’s biggest draws.

Drew recalled that their chemistry was instant—from their very first Zoom meeting, she knew Mooney was the perfect partner for the role. They bonded over a mutual friend, shared laughs, and quickly discovered a natural rhythm that translated beautifully to screen.

Before filming began, the two met for coffee in Pasadena. They spent hours talking and getting to know each other.

That early connection laid the foundation for their on-screen dynamic—a blend of warmth, humor, and simmering tension that fans can’t get enough of. Drew described Mooney as *a phenomenal actor and a generous leader*, praising his professionalism and kindness on set.

Together, they co-lead the series with equal parts heart and strength. Their partnership feels genuine and grounded.

Season 2 Turns Up the Heat

Season 2 of *Mistletoe Murders* promises to take that chemistry to new heights. The relationship between Emily and Sam is more layered than ever, filled with longing, frustration, and unspoken emotion.

The biggest obstacle between them remains Emily’s mysterious past—something she’s still hesitant to reveal. Sam, meanwhile, refuses to move forward without understanding the truth.

The tension between them builds as they’re forced to work together again. This time, they’re investigating a case that hits close to home: a shocking incident at Violet’s school.

As Drew teased, *the fighting is heated and spicy,* but it’s fueled by genuine affection and unresolved feelings. Fans can expect sparks—both emotional and romantic—as the duo navigates their complicated bond.

Unwrapping Emily Lane’s Past

One of the biggest fan requests after Season 1 was to learn more about Emily Lane’s backstory. Season 2 delivers on that in a big way.

Through a series of flashbacks, viewers will finally get a glimpse into Emily’s mysterious history, tracing her journey over several years. Drew revealed that a young actress portrays Emily in her early life, while she herself steps into a younger version of the character in later episodes.

This layered storytelling approach allows audiences to see how Emily became the woman she is today—strong, guarded, and endlessly intriguing. These flashbacks don’t just add emotional depth; they also tie directly into the central mystery of the season.

Every revelation about Emily’s past brings new insight into her present. The stakes are higher for both her personal life and her partnership with Sam.

Heart, Humor, and High Stakes

While *Mistletoe Murders* is rooted in suspense, Drew emphasized that Season 2 also brings plenty of warmth and laughter. The show’s charm lies in its balance—gritty enough to keep you guessing, but heartfelt enough to leave you smiling.

This season’s victims are more personal, connected to people the audience already knows and loves. That emotional investment makes each case hit harder, while also giving the characters room to grow.

Expect a mix of tones this season: heartfelt drama, witty banter, and fast-paced action. Drew described it best—there’s *a lot of heart, a lot of comedy, and a lot of action.*

Why *Mistletoe Murders* Matters

In a television landscape crowded with crime dramas, *Mistletoe Murders* stands out for its sincerity. It’s not just about solving cases; it’s about healing, forgiveness, and the power of connection.

Emily Lane isn’t your typical detective—she’s a woman with a past, a mother, and a survivor. Her journey mirrors the emotional complexity that Hallmark viewers have come to crave.

Under Sarah Drew’s leadership, the series has grown into something truly special: a cozy mystery with cinematic soul. Behind the scenes, Drew’s influence is unmistakable.

Her ability to blend creativity, compassion, and collaboration infuses every frame of the show. Whether she’s guiding a young actor, refining a scene’s emotional beats, or bringing Emily’s inner world to life, Drew’s fingerprints are everywhere.

She’s not just starring in *Mistletoe Murders*—she’s shaping its legacy. And honestly, that’s what makes the show worth watching.

What’s Next for Sarah Drew

As *Mistletoe Murders* keeps picking up steam, Drew’s future is looking especially bright. Her multi-hyphenate path—actor, writer, director, producer—kind of signals a fresh chapter for storytelling in Hollywood.

Women like her are really changing the whole idea of what it means to lead. She’s got this creative spark and seems to thrive on genuine teamwork.

Her work on *Mistletoe Murders* shows that heart and mystery can actually play nice together, which isn’t always easy to pull off.

With the holiday lights coming on and the mysteries piling up, fans have a lot to look forward to—passion, purpose, and, honestly, a few curveballs. When Sarah Drew becomes Emily Lane, it’s not just another Hallmark mystery.

It’s more like a heartfelt ride, wrapped up in red ribbon and dusted with just enough suspense to keep you guessing.

*Mistletoe Murders* airs Fridays at 8:00 p.m. ET/PT on Hallmark Channel.