Sarah Drew Reveals Delay Behind Mistletoe Murders Season 3 Renewal

The cozy charm of Hallmark’s Mistletoe Mysteries has captivated audiences for two seasons, with the latest run wrapping up on November 21. Fans are already buzzing, wondering if the network will deliver a third season of this holiday-themed mystery series.

Star Sarah Drew has been candid about the show’s uncertain future. The conversation around a possible renewal has sparked excitement—and, honestly, a bit of anxious energy—among viewers online.

Let’s take a look at what we know, what the cast is saying, and what Hallmark’s own history might suggest about the odds for another season of this festive favorite.

The Heart Behind Mistletoe Mysteries

Sarah Drew is at the center of Mistletoe Mysteries, wearing multiple hats as both lead actor and creative force behind the scenes. She’s called the series her “all-time favorite job,” a project that mixes her love of storytelling with her holiday spirit.

The show has built a loyal following thanks to its blend of small-town charm, heartfelt relationships, and those whodunits wrapped in Christmas lights. It’s more than just another Hallmark holiday movie—it’s a serialized mystery that keeps you guessing while still delivering that cozy comfort Hallmark is known for.

On November 19, during an appearance on the Pop Culture Unplugged podcast, Drew opened up about the show’s status. She sounded enthusiastic about continuing, but made it clear the team is “waiting on a season pickup.”

So, the future of Mistletoe Mysteries is in Hallmark’s hands. Without an official green light, there’s no moving forward with season three yet.

Why Sarah Drew’s Passion Matters

Drew’s dedication goes well beyond her on-screen role. As a producer, she’s deeply involved in shaping the show’s tone, characters, and vision.

Her commitment could be a big factor for Hallmark. When a star is this invested, networks usually take notice. Drew’s recent comments make it clear she’s ready to jump back in the moment Hallmark says yes.

Fans have noticed that passion, too. Social media is full of posts urging Hallmark to bring the show back.

This fan base could end up being a key reason the series gets another round of yuletide sleuthing.

The Fan Movement: A Holiday Rally Cry

As the last episodes of season two aired, fans took to social media platforms like X (formerly Twitter) to make some noise. The show even trended as viewers posted heartfelt messages pleading for renewal.

People are using hashtags, tagging the network, and sharing their favorite moments from the series to keep the buzz going. One viewer summed it up: “How could you not renew this show?” Another kept it simple: “Season three please!”

It’s not just Twitter, either. On Reddit’s Hallmark Movies community, discussions are packed with speculation, theories, and wish lists for a possible third season.

Plenty of fans say it’s a highlight of their holiday viewing every year.

What Fans Want in Season 3

From the online chatter, a few big wishes keep coming up:

• Longer episodes: Season two only had six episodes, airing over three weeks with double episodes each Friday. Fans are hoping for at least eight or ten next time.
• Deeper mysteries: Folks want more complex cases that keep them guessing until the very end.
• Character development: The core cast has become beloved, and viewers want to see those relationships grow.

These requests show just how invested people are in the show’s mix of mystery and holiday spirit. They’re not just asking for more—they want something even richer and more immersive than before.

Hallmark’s Track Record with Renewals

Hallmark has a reputation for listening to its audience, especially when fan enthusiasm gets loud. Past cases like The Three Wise Men and The Groomsmen movie series show that when viewers rally, the network often responds.

This gives hope that Mistletoe Mysteries could get a similar shot. Hallmark’s brand thrives on loyalty, and not many shows have sparked this much online engagement.

The network’s decisions, though, are usually pretty methodical. Hallmark tends to wait and see how ratings, social media, and streaming numbers look before committing to more seasons.

Since season two just ended, it might be a few months before we hear anything official.

Timing Could Be Everything

Hallmark’s programming calendar is packed with seasonal content, especially during the Countdown to Christmas period. If Mistletoe Mysteries returns to that slot, the soonest we’d likely see new episodes is late next year.

Any renewal news could drop in the spring or summer, giving the team time to prep for a holiday release.

In the meantime, Drew’s advice to “make as much noise as you can” rings true. Hallmark execs watch online engagement closely, and the louder the fans, the harder it is to ignore them.

Behind the Scenes: Why This Show Stands Out

Part of what makes Mistletoe Mysteries special is how it balances cozy holiday vibes with real suspense. The writers have found a formula that appeals to both mystery fans and Hallmark’s core romantic audience.

Each episode is a self-contained case, but there’s always a bigger story pulling you through the season. It’s just… satisfying in a way that’s hard to pin down.

Sarah Drew’s dual role as actor and producer adds something extra to the storytelling. Her influence shows up everywhere—from the way characters interact to the emotional beats that anchor each mystery.

It’s a rare combo that gives the show its unique feel—comforting, but with a little thrill mixed in.

The Power of Holiday Storytelling

Hallmark’s been the king of holiday programming for ages, but Mistletoe Mysteries feels like a fresh spin on that tradition. Instead of just focusing on romance, it weaves in intrigue, suspense, and even a touch of danger—all under twinkling lights and snowy streets.

This blend is pretty irresistible for viewers who want something a bit different from the usual holiday fare. And with streaming platforms and other networks ramping up their Christmas content, Hallmark’s ability to innovate in its own genre is going to matter more than ever.

Mistletoe Mysteries could be a perfect example of how to expand the brand while still keeping that classic Hallmark heart.

What Happens Next?

Right now, the fate of Mistletoe Mysteries is in Hallmark’s hands. The cast and crew are ready, fans are vocal, and demand is sky-high.

Will the network seize the momentum? If past experience means anything, the odds look pretty good—but it’s going to take some patience.

Until there’s an official announcement, fans can keep showing their support online. Every tweet, post, and comment helps signal to Hallmark that this is a show worth keeping around.

In TV, passion sometimes really does turn into power—and the Mistletoe Mysteries fandom has plenty of both.

A Hopeful Holiday Cliffhanger

As the year winds down, one thing is clear: *Mistletoe Mysteries* has become more than just a seasonal series. It’s starting to feel like a new holiday tradition.

Whether it comes back next year or takes a little breather, its mark on Hallmark’s holiday lineup is already set. Sarah Drew’s heartfelt commitment and the fans’ excitement say a lot, don’t they?

The network’s got a habit of rewarding loyalty, which honestly gives me hope for a bright, snow-dusted future. So keep your cocoa warm and your sleuthing instincts sharp.

And hey, don’t forget to keep those social media posts coming. If there’s one mystery I’d love to see solved this holiday season, it’s whether *Mistletoe Mysteries* gets the renewal it so clearly deserves.