Sarah Drew Teases Christmas Noir Magic in Mistletoe Murders

Hallmark fans, get ready to cozy up with a cup of cocoa and a side of suspense. The network is bringing back one of its most buzzed-about holiday mysteries — Mistletoe Murders.

After that jaw-dropping cliffhanger in Season 1, viewers have been itching for answers. The wait is almost over.

The first season will re-air starting Friday, October 18, at 8 pm ET/7 pm CT on the Hallmark Channel. Two episodes will air every Friday night.

The finale lands on October 31, just in time for a bit of Halloween chill. Then, Season 2 arrives November 7.

Starring Peter Mooney and Sarah Drew — who’s also stepping into a new behind-the-scenes role — this series promises a blend of cozy Christmas charm, romantic tension, and dark intrigue. It’s the kind of show that hooks you from the first snowflake to the final reveal.

The Return of Hallmark’s Most Intriguing Holiday Mystery

Hallmark’s known for heartwarming holiday tales, but Mistletoe Murders is switching things up. The show combines Hallmark’s festive glow with a moody, noir-inspired mystery.

If you’re craving more than just mistletoe kisses and gingerbread cookies, this one’s for you. Sarah Drew, famous from Grey’s Anatomy and Branching Out, leads as Emily Lane — a woman with secrets as deep as the snowdrifts around her small town.

Alongside Peter Mooney’s Sam Wilner, Drew’s character navigates a web of love, lies, and lethal secrets. It’ll keep you guessing week after week.

Missed the first run? Or just want to relive the twists? Hallmark’s giving fans the perfect chance to catch up.

A Flashback That Changes Everything

According to Drew, the moment that made her fall for the project hits at the end of the very first episode. There’s a flashback that turns everything you thought you knew upside down.

It’s the kind of twist that makes you pause, rewind, and rethink every character’s motive. Drew says it “explodes everything into a new light,” setting up a season packed with revelations and emotional stakes.

Fans of investigative dramas might catch shades of Veronica Mars or Alias in the show’s DNA. Drew describes Emily Lane as a woman leading a double life.

That tension — warm Christmas vibes clashing with the chill of murder — gives Mistletoe Murders its hook. It’s Christmas Noir at its best, and you can feel Drew’s excitement for the concept.

Sarah Drew’s Double Duty: Star and Executive Producer

Season 2 marks a big step for Sarah Drew. She’s back as the star, but now she’s also executive producer.

For Drew, it’s a creative dream. She’s shown she’s not just a talented actress but a storyteller with an eye for emotional depth.

Now, she shapes the show from both sides of the camera. As executive producer, Drew dives deep into everything — script tweaks, editing, the works.

She’s especially passionate about adding “extra romantic beats” and refining those moments that make Hallmark stories shine. Her approach is hands-on and collaborative.

Creative Control with a Heart

Drew’s talked about how much she loves the creative process, especially when it comes to leadership and collaboration. She thrives on shaping characters and guiding story arcs.

For her, executive-producing isn’t just about control — it’s about connection. There’s a warmth and intensity to her work that mirrors the very heart of Mistletoe Murders: complex, heartfelt, and full of surprises.

With Drew steering the ship, fans can expect more of what makes the show special — that blend of romance, mystery, and holiday spirit. Season 2 promises to keep the suspense razor-sharp while diving even deeper into the emotional stakes.

Why Mistletoe Murders Is the Holiday Hit You Didn’t Know You Needed

Hallmark’s built its empire on feel-good holiday movies, but Mistletoe Murders proves they can mix things up. The show balances cozy atmosphere with a darker, thrilling edge.

It’s a bold move that just works, offering a fresh take on holiday storytelling. Both longtime fans and newcomers looking for something with a little more bite will find something to love.

• Romance meets mystery: The chemistry between Emily and Sam is undeniable, but it’s the secrets between them that make their relationship so compelling.
• Festive yet foreboding: The show’s Christmas Noir aesthetic transforms twinkling lights and snow-covered streets into a backdrop for intrigue.
• Character-driven storytelling: Every episode peels back another layer of Emily’s past, revealing the truth behind her double life.

Each episode feels like unwrapping a gift — only to find something unexpected inside. The mix of heartfelt romance and chilling suspense gives Mistletoe Murders a unique place in the Hallmark lineup.

The Perfect Blend of Cozy and Creepy

It’s not easy to blend Christmas cheer and murder mystery, but Mistletoe Murders makes it look effortless. The show’s moody feel and atmospheric cinematography evoke nostalgia and unease at the same time.

It invites you to snuggle up, but keeps you on the edge of your seat. Drew’s take on Emily Lane adds real emotional depth, grounding the suspense in something human.

Fans of Hallmark’s traditional romances still get the small-town charm, the budding romance, the holiday spirit — but always with a twist. There’s a shadow behind the glow, a secret behind the smile.

And honestly, that’s what makes Mistletoe Murders so addictive.

Looking Ahead: What to Expect in Season 2

Hallmark’s keeping most Season 2 details under wraps, but the hints we’ve gotten suggest the stakes are about to get higher. With Drew helping to guide the creative direction, you can expect richer storytelling, deeper emotional arcs, and maybe more shocking reveals.

The mystery around Emily Lane’s true identity — teased all through the first season — is expected to take center stage again. Answers could change everything.

As the show continues, Mistletoe Murders isn’t just a seasonal novelty. It’s shaping up to be a Hallmark staple.

By blending genres and pushing boundaries, it’s redefining what a holiday series can be. With Sarah Drew leading on and off screen, the future looks bright — and just a little dangerous.

Final Thoughts

Maybe you’re in it for the romance. Or maybe it’s the mystery that hooks you.

*Mistletoe Murders* goes for both, blending holiday warmth with a bit of edge. It’s a strange, sweet mix—comfort and suspense, sugar and spice.

Hallmark’s stretching its legs here, trying something different while still holding onto that signature heart. I’ve got to admit, it’s kind of refreshing.

So, are you marking your calendar? Maybe grab some cocoa, settle in, and see what unfolds. This Christmas, the most wonderful time of the year just might come with a killer twist.