Stony Brook Graduate Shines on Hallmark Reality Show Finding Mr Christmas

There’s just something magical about the holiday season—the twinkling lights, cozy sweaters, and those heartwarming movies that somehow bring everyone together. This year, though, there’s an extra reason for festive TV fans to tune in.

Stony Brook University alumnus Craig Geoghan ’13 is stepping into the national spotlight as a contestant on Hallmark’s reality competition, Finding Mr. Christmas. The show follows ten hopefuls all vying for the title of Hallmark’s next leading man, and it’s already got viewers buzzing for a dose of holiday charm.

From his days on campus to his recent rise in Hollywood, Geoghan’s journey is a mix of determination, charisma, and maybe a little Christmas magic. The next episode airs Monday, November 17, at 8 p.m. on the Hallmark Channel, and you can also stream it free on the Roku Channel or Sling TV—so, honestly, why not grab some hot cocoa and root for one of Stony Brook’s own?

The Journey from Stony Brook to Stardom

Every great story starts somewhere, right? For Craig Geoghan, that place was Stony Brook University.

As a proud member of the Class of 2013, he honed his craft and built up the confidence that would later help him shine under Hollywood’s bright lights. Back at Stony Brook, he was always known for his energy, creativity, and this uncanny ability to connect with people—qualities that now make him stand out on Finding Mr. Christmas.

His path wasn’t always a straight line. But you get the sense that persistence and passion really can turn dreams into reality.

After graduation, Geoghan made the leap from academia to entertainment. He dove into the unpredictable world of auditions, callbacks, and casting calls.

It’s a journey plenty of aspiring actors dream about, but few actually pull off. Geoghan’s warmth and screen presence eventually caught the attention of Hallmark producers, who were on the hunt for someone to embody the spirit of their beloved holiday films.

Now, millions are watching as he competes to become the next face of Christmas romance.

A Show That’s More Than Just Competition

Finding Mr. Christmas isn’t your typical reality show. Sure, there’s competition and drama, but the heart of the series is really about kindness, connection, and community—the things that make Hallmark movies, well, Hallmark movies.

Each of the ten contestants brings something unique, but Geoghan’s authenticity and charm have quickly made him a fan favorite. As audiences tune in each week, they’re watching a group of dreamers chase their shot at spreading joy to millions.

Geoghan’s presence on the show is special for Stony Brook folks. His story is inspiring students and alumni, showing that the skills and spirit developed on campus can open some pretty incredible doors.

Whether he’s performing in front of a camera or connecting with fans online, Geoghan brings that Seawolf pride wherever he goes.

The Hallmark Magic: Why This Matters

Hallmark’s always been synonymous with holiday cheer, and its movies are a seasonal staple for a reason. But with Finding Mr. Christmas, the network’s shaking up its formula and letting viewers peek behind the scenes to see what it takes to become one of their leading men.

The show blends Hollywood glamour with small-town warmth, creating a feel-good experience that seems to resonate with fans of all ages. For Geoghan, this isn’t just a career milestone—it’s a chance to represent his alma mater and showcase his talent on a national stage.

His journey is a reminder that sometimes, success comes to those willing to take risks and stay true to themselves. That mix of courage and authenticity is what’s made him stand out among the competition.

What to Expect in the Next Episode

The upcoming episode, airing Monday, November 17 at 8 p.m., promises even more excitement as contestants face new challenges. They’ll have to show creativity, charisma, and capture that Hallmark holiday spirit.

Fans can expect heartfelt moments, a bit of fun, and maybe a few surprises. Whether you’re watching live or streaming, it’s one episode you probably don’t want to miss.

As the competition heats up, viewers are eager to see how Geoghan continues to shine. His natural ease on camera and genuine love for the holiday season make him a great fit for the Hallmark brand.

It’s honestly refreshing to see that even in a world filled with glitz and glamour, authenticity still wins hearts.

From Campus Dreams to Christmas Screens

Looking back, it’s pretty clear that Geoghan’s time at Stony Brook played a huge role in shaping his path. The university’s focus on creativity and innovation gave him the foundation to chase his passion.

Whether he was performing in student productions, collaborating with classmates, or learning from talented faculty, Geoghan made the most of every opportunity. Those experiences are serving him well now as he navigates reality TV and the entertainment biz.

His story also highlights the importance of community. Just as Stony Brook nurtured his early ambitions, Hallmark’s Finding Mr. Christmas offers a supportive environment where contestants lift each other up while chasing the same dream.

It’s a refreshing approach in a genre that’s usually all about rivalry. Instead of tearing each other down, these hopefuls actually build each other up—proof that the true spirit of Christmas is alive and well, both on and off screen.

How Fans Are Reacting

The response from fans? Overwhelmingly positive. Social media’s buzzing, with viewers sharing favorite moments and rallying behind their top contestants.

Geoghan, in particular, has struck a chord with people who appreciate his sincerity and down-to-earth personality. His growing fan base shows that authenticity and kindness really do come through, even on screen.

For Stony Brook alumni and students, the excitement runs even deeper. Seeing one of their own thrive on national TV fills them with pride and inspiration.

Many have taken to online forums and alumni groups to cheer him on. Once a Seawolf, always a Seawolf. Geoghan’s success feels like a shared win for the whole Stony Brook community.

Why You Should Tune In

If you’re into holiday movies or heartwarming stories, Finding Mr. Christmas deserves a spot on your watchlist. Maybe you just like watching people chase their dreams—there’s something special about that, right?

This show isn’t just another competition. It’s more like a celebration of hope and joy, with a dash of that unexpected magic we all kinda hope is real.

Craig Geoghan’s out there representing Stony Brook, and honestly, he does it with a lot of pride and passion. That alone makes it worth checking out, if you ask me.

So, if you’re curled up with a blanket or streaming on your phone, don’t miss the next episode this Monday night. You’ll probably laugh, maybe smile, and who knows—you might even start believing a bit more in Christmas dreams.