Why ‘Providence Falls: Thief of Fate’ is the Hallmark Movie You Can’t Miss This Year
Hallmark Channel’s latest fantasy romance trilogy wraps up with Providence Falls: Thief of Fate. This last chapter brings together the tangled love story of rookie detective Cora McLeod (Katie Stevens) and her partner Liam O’Connor (Lachlan Quarmby) as they try to figure out their destinies in the quirky little town of Providence Falls.
With their history tracing back to 1840s Ireland, the pair have to solve a big murder and larceny case. All the while, they’re up against cosmic forces—and their own messy emotions.
Find the best accommodations and airfares
Check availability at 5* hotels, guest houses and apartments rated "superb" or "exceptional" by visitors just like you.
NO RESERVATION FEES
CHECK AVAILABILITY FOR YOUR DATES HERE
Table of Contents
The Gist of Providence Falls: Thief of Fate
The film jumps in right where Part 2 left off. Liam finally kisses Cora after rescuing her from Magnus Cartwright (Samer Salem).
But when Cora wakes up in the hospital, Liam’s vanished. Her dad, former police chief James McLeod (Paul McGillion), wants her to drop the John Brady murder case, but Cora can’t let it go.
Meanwhile, Bael (Niall Matter), an agent from the Bad Place, keeps stirring up trouble. He uses Cora’s best friend Suzette (Felicia Simone), who’s got a complicated past of her own.
Unraveling the Past and Present
Suzette, once a cat burglar in turn-of-the-century Paris, gets a second shot at life in Providence Falls. She’s tangled up with Bael, working to keep Cora and D.A. office lawyer Finn Walsh (Evan Roderick) apart.
Liam trusts Suzette, not realizing she’s playing both sides. Suzette’s guilt grows as she genuinely cares for Cora and starts to fall for Finn.
Liam wants to tell Cora the truth about their past lives, but he’s bound by a promise to his angel overseers, Agon (Amitai Marmorstein) and Samael (Keegan Connor Tracy). Cora senses he’s holding back, and it starts to wear on her—especially with their investigation falling apart and Magnus walking free, thanks to Bael stepping in as his lawyer.
Cora sticks to the rules, while Liam’s more willing to bend them if it means getting justice.
Performance Highlights
The cast really brings it. Niall Matter stands out as Bael, the troublemaker—there’s a mischievous energy there that keeps things lively.
Katie Stevens and Lachlan Quarmby have real chemistry as the star-crossed leads, especially in the more emotional scenes.
Memorable Dialogue and Chemistry
The dialogue swings from heartfelt to genuinely funny. Liam’s awkward attempts to hide his jealousy over Cora and Finn are oddly endearing.
The romantic tension between Cora and Liam is hard to miss, and it gives the film a lot of its charm.
Plot and Storytelling
The movie opens with a quick recap, which is honestly helpful. There’s a lot of exposition, and the details of the investigation can get a bit overwhelming at times.
But at its core, the focus stays on the characters and their relationships. The story digs into fate, love, and redemption—can old mistakes be fixed, or are we just doomed to repeat them?
Strengths and Weaknesses
Character-driven moments are where Thief of Fate shines. Not everything is perfect, though.
Some storylines get wrapped up a little too neatly, while others are left hanging. The climax feels rushed and, honestly, a bit silly, but the film’s overall charm mostly makes up for it.
Breaking the Hallmark Mold
What really stands out is how this trilogy breaks away from the usual Hallmark formula. It’s a quirky mix of fantasy, romance, and mystery, with some genuinely original storytelling.
The creators play with familiar tropes, but they twist them just enough to keep things interesting.
Looking Forward
The success of Providence Falls opens the door for more creative Hallmark projects. It shows the network can take risks and pull off something a little different.
Fans of the trilogy will probably be keeping an eye out for what Hallmark dreams up next.
Stream It or Skip It?
If you’ve seen the first two parts of Providence Falls, Thief of Fate is one you’ll want to catch. It wraps up the series in a way that feels pretty satisfying.
New to the trilogy? The film’s recap and bits of exposition make it easy to jump in, though honestly, watching all three makes the whole thing land better. Grab some popcorn, get comfy, and dive into Providence Falls for what might be the last time.
- Performance Worth Watching: Niall Matter as Bael
- Memorable Dialogue: Liam’s awkward conversation about Cora and Finn
- Sex and Skin: None
Christmas Market Closures
Due to econonic conditions and tariffs, some Christmas Markets may cancel their events due to lack of vendors. If you are aware of a closed market,or find errors on a listing or an image, please reach out on our Contact Us page so that we may update this post.