Hallmark Begins Nationwide Search for First Mr Hallmark Christmas Experience

Hallmark is sprinkling extra holiday magic this year with a brand-new nationwide search that’s sure to melt hearts faster than a snowflake on a fireplace mantel. Inspired by the network’s hit holiday competition series Finding Mr. Christmas, the company is launching the first-ever Mr. Hallmark Christmas Experience—a festive showdown designed to find the ultimate embodiment of Hallmark holiday spirit.

Hosted by the ever-charming Jonathan Bennett and the effervescent Melissa Peterman, this competition promises laughter, love, and plenty of twinkling lights. From creative challenges to tests of kindness and charisma, contestants will compete for the coveted title of Mr. Hallmark Christmas Experience, along with a sleigh full of prizes.

And yes, it all culminates in a live event on December 7, 2025, at the Hallmark Christmas Experience. So, if you’ve ever dreamed of stepping into a Hallmark movie, this might just be your moment under the mistletoe.

The Search for the Ultimate Holiday Hero

Hallmark has long been the gold standard for holiday cheer—its movies, cards, and ornaments practically define the season. But now, the brand is taking its holiday storytelling off the screen and into real life.

The Mr. Hallmark Christmas Experience isn’t just another competition; it’s a celebration of everything that makes the season bright. The event invites men across the country to showcase their Hallmark-worthy qualities—warmth, humor, generosity, and maybe even a knack for decorating the perfect Christmas tree.

Contestants are asked to submit a 90-second video that captures their unique blend of charm and Christmas spirit. Whether it’s baking cookies, serenading with carols, or sharing heartfelt acts of kindness, Hallmark wants to see what makes each hopeful stand out as the ultimate ambassador of holiday joy.

The submission window closes at 11:59 p.m. CT on November 9, 2025, with selected participants notified by November 14. The anticipation is already building as fans wonder who’ll capture the crown—and the hearts of viewers nationwide.

What’s at Stake? A Prize Fit for a Christmas Movie Ending

Of course, no Hallmark story is complete without a magical reward. The winner of this merry competition will receive a one-of-a-kind grand prize package designed to make even Santa jealous:

• The coveted title of Mr. Hallmark Christmas Experience
• A stunning Balsam Hill Christmas tree to light up the winner’s home with holiday glow
• A meet and greet with Jonathan Bennett and Melissa Peterman, the dynamic duo behind Finding Mr. Christmas
• Two Hallmark Christmas Experience Be Merry packages for an unforgettable holiday adventure

A Celebration of Kindness, Charisma, and Christmas Spirit

What sets this competition apart is its focus on personality over perfection. Hallmark isn’t looking for a model in a Santa suit—it’s searching for someone who feels like Christmas.

The challenges are designed to test contestants’ creativity, compassion, and ability to spread joy. Think of it as a mix between a holiday pageant and a feel-good reality show, where the true measure of success is how much you can make others smile.

Each round of the competition will feature festive challenges that could include decorating, gift-giving, storytelling, or acts of kindness. The goal is to showcase the contestants’ ability to turn ordinary moments into magical memories.

And with Jonathan Bennett’s charm and Melissa Peterman’s comedic flair steering the sleigh, viewers can expect plenty of laughs and heartwarming moments along the way. It’s shaping up to be a memorable ride, honestly.

Hallmark’s Expanding Holiday Universe

This competition also signals a new chapter in Hallmark’s ongoing evolution. The brand has been steadily expanding its holiday empire beyond television, creating immersive experiences that bring fans closer to the magic.

The Hallmark Christmas Experience itself is a multi-week event filled with lights, music, and interactive attractions that capture the essence of a Hallmark movie in real life. Adding a live competition to the mix only deepens that connection, turning the audience into participants in the story.

And for fans who can’t make it to the event in person, Hallmark has made sure the spirit of the season is still accessible. Finding Mr. Christmas Season Two is currently airing on Hallmark Channel, with new episodes available the next day on Hallmark+.

Viewers can also catch up on Season One through a free seven-day trial of the streaming service. It’s all part of Hallmark’s mission to keep the holiday magic alive—on screen, online, and now, on stage.

How to Enter the Festive Fray

If you think you have what it takes to become Mr. Hallmark Christmas Experience, the process is as simple as it is spirited. Here’s how to join the fun:

• Visit the official Call for Submissions page.
• Submit a 90-second video showing off your holiday charm, humor, and heartfelt cheer.
• Be sure to upload before the deadline—November 9, 2025, at 11:59 p.m. CT.
• Keep an eye on your inbox; selected participants will be contacted by November 14, 2025.

Then, mark your calendar for Sunday, December 7, 2025, when the live event takes place during the second weekend of the Hallmark Christmas Experience. Tickets are already available at ExperienceHallmarkChristmas.com, and if past Hallmark events are any indication, they won’t last long.

Expect twinkling lights, festive décor, and maybe even a few surprise appearances from familiar Hallmark faces. Who knows what cozy magic they’ll have up their sleeves this year?

Why Fans Are Already Buzzing

Social media is already lighting up like a Christmas tree with excitement over the announcement. Fans are tagging their favorite Hallmark actors, suggesting potential contestants, and sharing their own videos filled with tinsel and cheer.

The idea of finding the ultimate Hallmark man—someone who embodies the warmth and humor of the brand’s beloved heroes—has captured the imagination of viewers everywhere. It’s a clever move by Hallmark, blending the nostalgia of its movies with the interactivity of modern entertainment.

By inviting fans to participate directly, the network continues to strengthen its emotional bond with audiences who crave connection and comfort, especially during the holiday season. If you ask me, it’s a welcome spark in a season that could always use a little more joy.

A New Tradition Is Born

For decades, Hallmark has been pretty much the face of Christmas. From those cozy movies to the classic keepsake ornaments, the brand has built an empire around the idea that love and kindness can change the world—one snow-covered town at a time.

The *Mr. Hallmark Christmas Experience* is the next step in that journey. Now, viewers can actually become storytellers and step straight into their own Hallmark moment.

Maybe you’ve been a fan forever. Or maybe you just crave a little extra holiday spirit when the weather turns cold.

Either way, this event is shaping up to be one of the season’s warmest highlights. It’s all about the best parts of Christmas: community, joy, and that wild hope that magic could show up when you least expect it.

So, if you’re tempted, dust off your Santa hat and warm up some cocoa. This December, Hallmark’s at it again—reminding us that, honestly, nobody does Christmas quite like they do.

Curious? For all the details—and to jump into the festivities yourself—visit ExperienceHallmarkChristmas.com. Get ready to step into a world where every twinkle light has a story, and every smile feels like coming home.