The Stars Between Us Review: A Fate-Filled Hallmark Romance

Hallmark’s latest Loveuary offering, The Stars Between Us, shoots romance straight into the cosmos. Fan-favorite Sarah Drew teams up with Matt Long in a story that leans into fate, timing, and the magnetic pull of destiny.

Set during a rare total solar eclipse, the film explores missed connections, second chances, and that age-old question—can love really be written in the stars? With a softer, more reflective tone than most Hallmark romances, it’s already got devoted viewers talking.

A Love Story Guided by the Cosmos

At the heart of The Stars Between Us is a meet-cute that feels intimate but somehow huge. Malcolm, an applied physics student obsessed with astronomy, shows up at an eclipse viewing with a telescope and a lot of enthusiasm.

That’s where he meets Kim, who’s more of a casual stargazer. What starts as a shared moment under the darkened sky quickly hints at something deeper.

This isn’t your usual whirlwind romance, though. Instead of racing toward forever, the story takes its time.

Malcolm and Kim go their separate ways after that first connection, leaving us with that bittersweet ache of what could’ve been.

Seven Years Later: When Fate Circles Back

Jump ahead seven years. Another eclipse is coming, and the cosmos seem to mirror the film’s emotional arc.

The second eclipse isn’t just a scientific event—it’s a metaphor for timing, destiny, and the unpredictable orbit of love.

Rather than piling on grand gestures, the film leans into possibility. There’s a focus on the space between moments, not just the moments themselves.

This reflective tone is what makes the story stand out from most of its Loveuary siblings.

Sarah Drew Shines in a Fan-Favorite Return

Bringing Sarah Drew back for another Hallmark lead is both strategic and heartfelt. With her hit series Mistletoe Murders just wrapping season two and already renewed, she’s definitely a familiar face for the network’s loyal crew.

Here, Drew’s performance feels grounded and sincere. Kim is relatable—curious, warm, and easy to root for.

Drew brings nuance to the role, letting us feel every flicker of hope and hesitation. She’s got that rare ability to make even the quietest moments land.

Matt Long’s Return to Romantic Leading Man Status

It’s been a minute since Matt Long headlined a Hallmark romance, but he slips right back into the role. As Malcolm, he’s got intellectual passion but never comes off as cold or distant.

His excitement about astronomy is honestly contagious. You get why Kim would be drawn into his orbit.

Drew and Long share a connection that feels authentic, even though the film keeps their couple time limited on purpose. That choice might split viewers, but it gives the story a rhythm that’s different from the usual fare.

An Unconventional Structure That Defies Expectations

One of the boldest moves in The Stars Between Us is how little time the main couple actually shares on screen. For a channel built on cozy, chemistry-driven romances, this is a bit of a gamble.

The film shifts focus to their parallel growth and the new connections they form during the years apart. It’s less about instant gratification, more about the long game.

Why This Choice Works — And Why It Might Not for Everyone

Some folks might wish for more face-to-face time between Malcolm and Kim. Hallmark fans are used to slow burns with plenty of shared laughter and longing glances.

But this film leans into introspection. It asks us to think about timing and fate—how sometimes, meaningful connections can survive even long stretches of absence.

• A celestial theme that ties romance to rare astronomical events
• A reflective narrative style focusing on possibility rather than certainty
• Strong lead performances anchored by Sarah Drew and Matt Long
• A Loveuary lineup motif centered on destiny and otherworldly forces

Loveuary’s Ongoing Obsession with Fate

This year’s Loveuary movies all seem to share a thread: destiny. Each film so far leans into fate, coincidence, or maybe even a bit of cosmic nudging to bring couples together.

The Stars Between Us might take that theme the most literally. The eclipse isn’t just a backdrop—it’s the story’s heartbeat, symbolizing alignment, shadow, and illumination.

Romance Written in the Stars

There’s something undeniably appealing about love being guided by forces we can’t control. The film taps into that longing, hinting that missed connections can come back around when the stars finally align.

By weaving together science and sentiment, you get Malcolm’s analytical mind balanced with Kim’s openness. It’s a romance that feels grounded yet a little enchanted—a dance between logic and longing.

Should You Stream or Watch Live?

If you’re a Hallmark fan, this one’s basically required viewing. It’s up on Hallmark+ and premiered on the Hallmark Channel on February 21, so you can catch it live or stream it at your own pace.

What makes it worth a look isn’t just the star power or those picturesque eclipse visuals. It’s the film’s willingness to try something a bit different inside the familiar Hallmark world.

A Starry Story with a Distinct Voice

Lots of viewers probably wish the leads shared more scenes. Still, there’s something kind of bold about a romance that sits with emotional distance instead of rushing past it.

The pacing? It’s gentle. The performances feel sincere, not forced.

There’s a strong sense of theme running through it all. The show doesn’t spoon-feed its audience, either.

The Stars Between Us trusts that you’ll appreciate a quieter, more contemplative love story. It doesn’t chase constant swoon-worthy moments—maybe that’s for the best.

What it offers instead is something that lingers: the idea that some connections are just meant to find their way back together. Isn’t that what we all hope for, at least a little?

This season is packed with stories that stick to the usual formula. But this one looks up and wonders about timing, fate, and those invisible threads we can’t quite explain.

If you’ve ever found yourself questioning whether the universe has a plan for your love life, this Hallmark gem might just give you a little hope. Or at least a reason to look up at the stars and wonder.